All - Thank you for the different perspectives. It really helped me come to a decision on this. If you're interested, I decided to stop negotiations for the following reasons:
- This was a deal that would get me virtually no equity. Only way I could build equity was to put the cash flow back into the principle, which would restrict me from building my portfolio further.
-This was too big of a leap to sign up for managing a property this size not knowing if I even liked managing short term rentals.
- To the points above, property manager would be 25%, which would not make this deal profitable. And also, the fact that they're selling it at a business price as opposed to the real estate, which does not fly in this market.
-Lastly, this deal would not work (at least not well enough) with long term renters, leaving me no fall back plan.
Thanks again for all of the input. This has been truly educational for me.
Also special shoutout to the Asheville people who gave market insight, @Doniel Winter, @Lauren B., @Cindy Coker, @Jon A.