Thanks again @Michael Baum. Yes the lack of identical apples-to-apples comps has been an issue in the area for years. Appreciate you taking a quick look but Steilacoom is a different market than North Tacoma. The unobstructed water views for both front STR units can be challenging to determine additional value compared to other 3-unit properties without views. With the massive increase in STR properties in the US, I am hopeful that lenders and appraisers will evolve to apply income/exp metrics to STR deals specifically, on top of generic property comps.
@Nathan Gesner Yes, I'm fairly confident if we were to hold long term, we'll do just fine. I want to exit as I don't get any personal use from the STR being 20 mins from home and would rather apply the capital to another opportunity in multifamily (LTR) or another STR in Hawaii where my brother is a broker and now manages STRs. My regret is not buying one in Hawaii or somewhere else where my family could spend some vacation time. Plus STRs are not the model for me. We bought it because it is a beautiful property in solid location and I wanted to learn the STR model. It's too much like the hospitality business rather than a rental. If I didn't have two amazing biz partners, I would have already likely sold it.
BTW, I could have mentioned earlier, when we refi'd in 2022 the appraiser came in at 1,300,000 and verbally told me that he struggled as he believed the property was likely worth more based on the location, views, income. I was able to push back and provided more data, he adjusted to $1,335,000.