Chris Clothier I hope you didn't take my post the wrong way. I was just pointing out that there is also a good way to execute this strategy. I understand you didn't mean that people were doing anything wrong but that they could get themselves into trouble. I completely agree with you that "cash out" shouldn't be the magic words to do a deal. That's a terrible strategy if they can't support the debt load. As long as you are conservative, as with anything else you a much less likely to get yourself in trouble. I personally only purchase properties that will leave me with a lot of free cash flow even if leveraged up to 75%. If they don't, it's not a good rental. It may be a good flip but not a good rental. In that case it should just be sold.
I wouldn't think too many banks are being aggressive on their values these days. They certainly were before the crash but it seems they have done a complete 180. I've had the opposite problem in several deals recently. In one appraiser was comparing a trashed out bank foreclosure to a property that just recently had a full rehab like it was an apple to apple comparison. I eventually got him to come up to the sales price by sending him a few decent comps.
The properties I am looking to pull money out of fit this scenario perfectly. The one was purchased a year ago and the other several months ago. We paid cash, rehabbed them, and rented them out. They are both 2 units, provide great cash flow, and with purchase+rehab are still below 70% of market price.
Everyone makes mistakes, I certainly have. lol Anyone with a business the size of yours certainly has and it sounds like you have an absolutely amazing business. You just can't be successful without making some mistakes. You have to try to learn from others mistakes and when you can't, make sure they are not career ending mistakes. Once again I completely agree with you that you could get into trouble if your focused on the wrong thing and that is true of many strategies. There are good ways to implement them and bad ways also.