For all the math geeks out there, here's a question on how to handle Capex in your Cash-on-Cash calculation.
- Bought a property for $150,000 already rented
- After 12 months I did a $6,000 renovation I knew going in I had to do.
I could have done that from the get-go and bundle all up as my initial cash invested, but I waited 12 months and did the renovations later.
Now I'm trying to figure out the right math, and it gives me completely different results:
1. Consider the $6k renovations as an expense:
- Total Cash Invested: $35,000
- Net Annual Income: $4,000 cashflows - $6,000 renovations = -$2,000
- Cash-on-Cash Return = Net Annual Income / Total Cash Invested = -5.7%
2. Consider the $6k as part of the initial investment, even though it happened 12 months later:
- Total Cash Invested: $35,000 + $6,000 renovations = $41,000
- Net Annual Income: $4,000 cashflows
- Cash-on-Cash Return = +9.7%
In one scenario I end with -5.7% and the other +9.7%, just by the way I move that $6k expense.
I don't want to play the numbers and make a fool of myself, so I was wondering how you guys would handle this :)