I agree with @Heather Cunningham !
In addition to using AirDNA, research active and potential competitor rentals in your target market near Gatlinburg by browsing booking platforms. Take a close look at both the property types, analyzing their average nightly rates and occupancy trends.
As you search for investment properties, consider those with both pools and stunning views. This will allow you to run specific underwriting and projection tools to better assess each option.
Remember, owning a property with a pool comes with added expenses, such as heating, emergency and routine maintenance, and higher insurance costs. Keep this in mind when calculating potential profitability.
Research active and potential competitive rentals in your intended market near Gatlinburg, not just through AirDNA, but searching booking platforms. Analyze both property types including the average nightly rates and occupancy rates.
As you search for properties I would be open to viewing both properties with pools and amazing views. From here, you can analyze specific properties and run underwriting and projection tools.
Keep in mind that running a property with a pool does incur more expenses, heating the pool, emergency maintenance, standard maintenance, higher insurance, etc.