Hi @Bryan Clark, I am a novice compared to most people on BP. I have only 3 units and I'm getting ready to close on 4th but all of mine are SFR so I am in that space. I am far more conservative than most investors so I take all of the ways to make money into consideration i.e. cashflow, appreciation, ROI, and tax benefits. The first "weed-out" question I always consider is: what % of the purchase price is the rent? If you are suggesting the two units will rent for $1200/mo, your looking at 1.2%. For me, 1.2% is my starting rate. I won't really look at anything below that, but again, I'm very conservative. A lot of others will look at cap rate, but IMO, I only care about cap rate if I'm investing in cash. When financing, it is less important. Other questions are important such as: will it appreciate? How much do you expect to go towards expenses of an old home? After the current tenant moves out, how will you fill vacancy? If you expect those to items to be high/difficult, I'd grade the investment as a C+/B-. If you expect it to appreciate and your cashflow really is $5k/yr after all expenses, your ROI time is about 4ish years which probably makes it a B+ investment. Again, just one man's opinion. Good luck!