OK, I started in the middle of the story because of what was going on with the eviction, and how I avoided dealing with that myself. Someone requested the numbers, so here they are. :)
The property is in an improving neighborhood*, and was initially listed for $94,900. Advertised rents were $520 for the downstairs 2 bedroom unit, and $400 for the upstairs 1 bedroom unit. I know that in nice condition, rentals in that neighborhood should go for $600-$650 downstairs and $500-525 up. To bring them up to that standard, I would need new flooring, paint, and probably a new bathroom upstairs. Downstairs has the old woodwork that is in great condition, remodeled bathroom, new laundry room, and some new flooring.
After 60 days the price dropped to $79,900. I put in an offer for $72,000 and accepted a counter for $75,000. Repairs estimated at $14,200. I got a loan at 80% ltv for $71,360 (repair costs rolled into the loan). It is a 20 year business loan with a 3 year balloon @ 4.5%
- Purchase Price + Repairs $89,200
- My down payment is $17,840.
- Assuming rents of $1100
- 7% vacancy rate is $77
- Maint $100
- Water & Sewer $50
- Property tax $144
- Insurance $60
- P&I of $436
- Cash Flow $232
Cash on cash return of 16%
If I get the upper end of the rents, cash flow would be $302, for a coc of 21%. ;) I have my other rentals with a management company for 8% of the rents, but I think we will try our hand at managing this one ourselves.
* The neighborhood was not a desirable place a few years ago. But investors have bought up properties and fixed them up. Home owners took heart and have also fixed up their houses, and most of the problems have moved out.