I'd recommend an LLC simply because it's cheap and limits any liability on you personally. Not sure how you'll work that if you've already purchased the house personally. I'm not sure it matters who the check is written to, as the house is in your personal name. I was taught, if something catastrophic happens at the home (fire, flood, death, etc.) and the tenants sue you - they can, technically, only get what the LLC "owns". So, if they sue you for 500k and your LLC owns a house worth 100k and the judge rules in their favor, then they get the house. If it's in your personal name then they can come after your personal assets such as vehicles, retirement, 401k ,etc. Hence the "Limited Liability Corporation". Also, I carry extra insurance for this very reason. All is well until someone gets hurt. A lawyer could probably clarify this, but this is how I understand it to work and why (smart) people do not rent homes personally.