Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Brendon W.

Brendon W. has started 3 posts and replied 19 times.

Post: Tenant Won't Answer and I Don't Have Keys to the Property

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8

Hey Andrew,

Disclaimer here, I'm very new to the landlording side of this discussion but I'm a police officer in PA and I've responded to calls from landlords many times. Number one, I'd say obviously be very careful about forcibly entering someone's apartment (especially in Philly). While properly posting the notice leaves you within your rights to do this, I'm assuming you've never met this person before so you don't know exactly what is on the other side of that door. People are getting crazier and crazier with everything going on so just be cognizant of that and bring a third party if possible. Secondly, just make sure you have everything documented like @Jim K. said, post the notice, take photos, and have the landlord / tenant law documents handy in case things do go south and you have to call the police because I can tell you, most aren't familiar with these laws. I'd also consider calling the local police ahead of time if you are going to be drilling out any locks in case your tenant decides he's calling the police himself to report a burglary in progress in which case you don't want them to roll up on you taking a drill to someone's door. Lastly, if you lock the tenant out, make sure you answer your phone. I had a landlord do this once and the tenant called the police to report it. When I showed up I made several attempts to contact the landlord myself with no answer so I actually had to let the tenant drill out the new locks himself because all of his belongings were still inside and he hadn't been legally evicted. 

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8

I actually have a follow up question somewhat on the same subject. If the Zillow listing says "3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms" and County Assessment records say "2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom," what does that discrepancy mean? Square footage is the same on both but I'm seeing a lot of differences when it comes to the rooms. Does this pose any kind of potential permitting issue for a future buyer? It's like watching the news...I don't know what to believe.  

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Anthony Angotti:
Originally posted by @Brendon W.:

I'm sure this question has been asked 1000 times on this site at this point, but I'm wondering if anyone has some market specific insight for the Pittsburgh Area.

I'm trying to run some comps on a single family home and I'm not sure how much I should be adjusting for extra bedrooms and bathrooms. J. Scott uses 3% of the sale price for an extra bedroom but I'm sure this varies from market to market. 

Any rules of thumb to use for 2 bedrooms compared to 3 bedrooms...3 bedrooms compared to 4 bedrooms? 1 bath compared to 2...2 compared to 3, etc. ?

Also, one of the homes I was using as a comp was excellent (same style, general floor plan, age, sq. footage) but it had a pool in the backyard. I just threw something out there and subtracted $10K although I have no idea how much an inground pool would affect the price in Western PA where you get about 4 months a year to use it. Maybe I shouldn't have even used that home as a comp..

I appreciate any feedback.

Thanks! 

 You need to run comps for an area and control for bedroom/bathroom count as much as you can. There is no standard adjustment, it's based on neighborhood.

Pools are really no value add at all, and in many cases are actually a negative value factor. However depends on the price range like everything else, but I'm assuming this is not a luxury property. 

Negative, it's what I would consider a B class neighborhood. That was my thinking as well, I personally wouldn't want to purchase a home with a pool at this stage in life but certain buyers with children might pay a premium for the property. 

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @John Hinnant:

Another tip would be to use Zillow or Redfin and calculate the $/SqFt of sold properties vs active listings and look at the differences in sizes. Having MLS data would be most helpful, might be worth calling an agent or appraiser in the area and shooting them some Venmo money to pull data for you and email it in excel.

Okay that's helpful. I wasn't aware that MLS data could be imported to excel like that and I'm hesitant to ask for favors that might only be beneficial to me so it'll make me feel better about it to offer some compensation.

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Victoria Pham:

@Brendon W. Are you talking about the comp for rehab budget? I would use the price per squarefoot typically in that area to find the added cost

In this particular instance I found a listing that was FSBO and it was a 3 bed / 1 bath SFH so I wanted to determine what the approximate value of the house would be given that FSBO listings tend to be overpriced by the owner. I also wanted to figure out how much value an additional bathroom would bring as this would be a live-in flip scenario. I can just shoot the listing to my agent for comps but I also wanted to try and figure it out on my own to familiarize myself with the process.

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @John Hinnant:

Avoid 2 vs 3 bedroom comps. I typically export the neighborhood sales into excel and calculate the contributory value of incremental increases in square footage. It depends neighborhood by neighborhood, but if you can collect close to 100 (3 bedroom +) sales within a mile or two radius, you’ll have some statistical data you can rely on. Band the homes in square footage ranges 500-1000 SqFt increments. It’s a little complicated to explain on a forum, but it’s a technique I use in my appraisal business when working in a tea I haven’t been in over a year or two. I also do matched pairs for swimming pools. I’ve found 6% of sales price is a fair adjustment. A lot of folks just use $10,000, but that’s usually what you lose in the cost of building a pool. For example: a pool might cost $25,000 to build, but the contributory value might be $15,000. 

Okay thank you so much for the tip! I don't have a RE license so I don't have direct access to the MLS, do you think using zillow / redfin and entering the sales data into Excel would be sufficient? I'm not sure how accurate that information is but I can also cross reference with County records. There's often discrepancies between the two regarding square footage because the listing agent sometimes includes finished basements that the County assessment office doesn't recognize.

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Aaron K.:

@Brendon W. totally depends on price point and size and obviously diminishing returns as you increase in size, the 1,000th sqft is worth more than the 4,000th sqft.  Also try bracketing your subject if possible, if you picked one comp 100 sqft smaller, try to find one that is 100 sqft bigger as well.

Okay that makes sense I never thought of doing that. Thanks for the help!

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Ryan Hannas:

Got it, thanks.

What Aaron said applies here as well, with some variation depending on the specific neighborhood of the home (e.x., I would not compare most homes in Dormont to homes in Bethel or Bridgeville).  Going from 2 to 3 beds could add $15-20k - 3 to 4 beds, $3-5k - same with baths, 1 to 1.5 or 2 is huge, going to 3 baths not so much. Are you working with an agent?  They should be able to provide you with some accurate data for the specific house in which you’re interested.  

Okay thanks for the info that helps a lot. Yeah I'm working with an agent, but I'm pretty new to all of these concepts so I'm just trying to get a grasp of how to do this stuff on my own to get a general idea when I see something come up. 

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Ryan Hannas:

Hi Brenden - what area in Pittsburgh?

I've been targeting the South Hills area. Specifically Dormont, Bethel Park, Carnegie, Bridgeville in addition to some areas in Washington County like Canonsburg and Houston. 

Post: Comp Adjustments for Pittsburgh Area

Brendon W.Posted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Posts 20
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Aaron K.:

Not specific to Pitt, but in general try not to comp 2 beds to 3 beds if at all possible.  3 to 4 is usually anywhere from $2k to $5k 4 to 5 and beyond that is usually negligible, and square footage is what counts.  Pools are a big deal in some places like CA, AZ, FL in PA I'd assume it is more like 10k-12k as opposed to $20k-$25k+ in the others.

 Thanks Aaron. 

What kinds of adjustments are you making for square footage? I try to keep the comps within 10% but if there's a difference of a hundred sq. feet or so I'm not sure what degree of adjustment to make although I'm sure it depends on the size. 

Yeah I found a wide range in adjustments for pools in the forums but naturally those coming from perpetually warm climates were factoring in a larger adjustment. Here we get a few good months out of them and the rest of the year its basically a hole filled with nasty tepid water or ice so a lot of buyers might just see them as money pits.