Hi @Mike Bend, welcome to the BP community! You’ll learn a lot here. I’m from the Chicago NW burbs as well, we’ll have to connect offline and grab a coffee sometime. My thoughts on your post is if you owe $169K and sell it for $230K. After you expenses for closing you are only netting $45K (assuming a 6% realtor) at best. Ask yourself what can you do with $45K to trade up or level up. Keep in mind the hot market will work against you when you are trying to buying your next asset. Also right now it’s extremely hard to buy at a discount unless property needs a lot of work. Are you connected with any local wholesalers? Might want to feel out what you could trade up to first?
Side question, how long have you had the current mortgage in place (since last refi)? Sometimes that factor should be considered in keep it or sell it. For example if you’ve had for 12-13 years and paid down a lot of the interest of a 30 years mortgage in the first 15, the back 15 of the 30 year you pay down principal a lot faster.
Either way, hope this helps and good luck!