I probably should have renamed the thread to something like "My 1st month experience with rental property..." instead of "My 1st month experience with out of state turnkey property...". I didn't mean to make it seem like it was the "out of state turnkey" thing that was bad. In fact, my experience has actually been very good with the whole process of investing out of state and the people I have dealt with so far have all been amazing. I don't want this to discourage people from investing out of state or in turnkeys, because as Dawn stated, this was more of a freak accident that could happen anywhere. I just needed to rant...
Luckily, my PM has been great and has taken control of the situation so that I don't have to deal with it. They have already boarded up the hole in the house to prevent any water damage and hopefully will have the driver's insurance cover everything.
Also, good advice on getting an engineer/inspection done on the foundation of the house. I don't plan on selling anytime soon, but it's better to get it fixed now when its covered.