Quote from @Paul Florez:
Hello all,
First and foremost, thank you to everyone who has given so much knowledge the last few years as I dipped my toes into real estate. I have been a long time reader absorbing everything I can. I hope to contribute as I grow myself and help others.
For this discussion, I have a duplex cash flowing $1,500/month with $220k in equity. I am trying to scale up my portfolio. If you were in my shoes, which of the following options would you choose and why? Oh and I already have a HELOC for $50k. Thank you in advance!
1) Refinance property @ 90% ltv which leaves me with $157k (closing costs included in the new loan) but would be -$300 in cash flow in my current property.
a) Buy a commercial multifamily property between 5 and 10 units to get my feet wet in commercial real estate.
b) Buy a cash flowing property in the Midwest for under $200k with 20% down AND house hack a duplex/triplex possibly in Albany, NY.
2) Wait another year to build more equity and get a HELOC @ 90% ltv and use those funds to buy more multifamily properties and keep my current cash flowing property.
Looking forward to hearing from ya'll!
Hey Paul, Its great to have you here and contributing.
Understanding your long term goals is important in making a decision like this. There are a couple of ideas with real estate that most people shoot for.
1. Reduce Taxes through depreciation (If you don't meet the IRS definition of a real estate professional, it won't improve any W-2 income taxes)
2. Cash flow - smaller MF like these can take a few years to start seeing decent cash flow, so having positive cash flow early is a positive as it typically (not always) grows over time.
3. Equity / Capital Gains - This is usually a shorter term timeline. Buy a value add, improve property and rents, resell for the gain.
4. Contribution - some want to provide good housing options.
Most will have a combination of all these factors.
QUESTIONS.
What type of cash flow are you looking to generate? By when?
Adding a 5-10 unit will increase your expense exposure initially until you raise rents to cover costs. Within 12-18 months you should see a positive return helping you get back to the $1500 cash flow you're used to. Over time, more units = more cash flow. Additionally, a larger property like this is valued based on the actual cash flow, not sales comps, so you have the ability to force appreciation faster with efficient management.
Adding the a 5-10 unit may also increase the amount of time you spend getting you closer to the 'Real Estate Professional' status for tax purposes opening up room for offsetting some W-2 income on taxes.
Waiting as an option. The current environment is shifting again. Indicators are showing that price drops in the MF sector may be near bottom, and activity is picking up in the coming year. That will drive prices up. Rule of thumb is that waiting in real estate rarely pays off. Find the right deal and take action sooner rather than later.
With supply constraints and dropping interest rates, more activity will increase demand for this type of property. A year from now, that decision will cost you more than you'll be able to save or build in equity.
Besides. A year from now, you will still have the option for a 90% HELOC.
Best wishes to you.