@John Chapman
Thanks for the response. "...over thinking the buy and hold business a bit." LOL! BINGO! Do you have a spycam in my office??
Sorry for the confusion but I guess what I was getting at was a way to better track my numbers and know how well/poorly each property is doing. For example:
Here is my real life scenario today... feel free to drop your 2 cents on this one. I am thick skinned and open to learning.
I have a 4 bed, 2.5 bath, 2500sqft SFR that I have owned for 6.5 years. It has had tenants in it from day 1 with no real improvements from me other than a new dishwasher. Purchase price was $245k in 8/2008 (REO) with 20% down. It is now on a 15 year fixed which started in 10/2010 at 4.125%. That 2010 refi cost me about $3k. Current PITHI is about $1887/mo and rent is $2100/mo. Mortgage balance is about $150k and zestimate is $325k.
Current tenants are moving out this spring 2015 and I want to bump rent to about $2400/mo. It is in the process of getting a new roof and exterior paint due to a hail storm last summer (putting that insurance policy to work). What improvements should I consider and what budget to increase my cashflow? It desperately needs new flooring throughout (original 2001 carpet in place). My plan is to do a laminate type product on the entire first floor, carpet on the stairs and upstairs (plus buy an extra 6 feet to redo stairs in about 5 years). Other than that it has laminate counter tops, golden oak cabinets, brass fixtures, 4 inch white tile baths, you get the idea... 2001.
Based on my research of comps on rentals.com it is very obvious that there is a line somewhere of diminishing returns when updating a rental, but I haven't been able to exactly pinpoint it yet. That is what has brought me back to ROI, ROE, COC, etc... there has got to be some way for the math to tell me how much I should spend on this house and avoid the over improvement trap...
Currently working my way through "The Real Estate Investor's Pocket Calculator" to better understand the metrics and ratios I should be using. Other properties have required improvements and refinancing over the years and I am now trying to evaluate where each individual property stands as far as being profitable compared to other opportunities out there (multifamily?)