Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Benjamin Giles

Benjamin Giles has started 10 posts and replied 22 times.

Quote from @Alex Hunt:

At this current point in the market I would look more at a prepayment buy down instead of a rate buy down, as you most likely won’t keep the rate you get now for the term of the loan. 
For the points available do you mean that you are allowed to buy down? Or what you’re being charged? Either combine into the same top line figure essentially, with the Max varying per lender but typically 4.25% max 


Happy to run through this further!


 Wow, interesting! Hadn't thought about asking to buy down the prepayment.

Thanks Nate

What I have been working on over the last 6 months. (Not actively purchasing as my money is tied up in the market right now)...so with the 2 lenders i've gotten here:

STR DSCR Rural (not a log cabin or other non-conforming structure) just remote sfr

Hybrid loan 15% down, interest only investment loan with seller paid points to get to ~8% and reduce closing costs 

DSCR would use long term rental rates to establish monthly DSCR and then offset monthly with average DTI and 800+ credit and high cash reserves as long as DSCR is .75+

additional appraisal to establish STR rate estimates to be used alongside the standard long term rental rates

5 year prepayment penalty with reasonable terms

Quote from @Nate Herndon:

Hi @Benjamin Giles, happy to answer this as best I can from the DSCR lending partner perspective. This is based on a few dozen private lender programs that I utilize for my clients.

o Rate buydown ratio: Current norm is a 4:1 ratio, or 1% fee for 0.25% off of rate. A 3:1 ratio or 1% fee for 0.375% might be available. The rate that you buy down to is your rate for the entirety of your 30-year fixed loan - it is not a stepdown like you might see on some conventional loan products. Some programs will let you spend as much as you like to buy the rate down (to their rate floor), while others do have a cap of 3-5% max buydown like you mentioned.

o Seller concessions: The typical max allowed seller concession on a DSCR loan is going to be 2-3% of the loan amount. The rate buydown is simply a part of your closing costs, so if you work a 2% seller concession into your contract and want to consider that the 'seller-paid buydown' then that's up to you.

o Rate floor: You are going to eventually hit a rate floor with any loan program, or a point where you cannot buy the rate down any further. That varies from lender to lender. One of my favorite programs offers a rate floor down to 7.50% right now, but their par rates are more competitive (i.e. without a buydown). Another lender offers rates down to 5.75%, but they are more costly to get there.


Thanks Nate. And these are commercial investment loan? also are they available for purchase under LLC with individual credit and acceptable DTI?

Does anyone have, or is anyone aware of a calculator with inputs to show me whether a seller paid 3-2-1 rate buy down vs price reduction is best, where I have ability to input for how many years. 

I have seen very basic versions that only show the lifetime savings after 30 years but I want to be able to input variables for rate, points, number of years, and price reduction.

Has anyone had success in buying down rates on single family with commercial loan? Also, from any lenders out there...are the same number of points available for purchase as with a standard residential mortgage? (seems like 3-4 points is the max out for most)

Quote from @Glen Wiley:

I haven't seen this lately but be careful and read the terms - there are often terms in the mortgage that preclude using the second home as an income property or limit the number of days you can be paid rent on it. Violating the terms of a mortgage is mortgage fraud and can be a real pain if it becomes an issue.


 Thanks Glen...looking at that chart it seems that the rate adjustments are the same for investment property and second home. Maybe it's better to go in designating it as investment property if all terms are the same?

Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Benjamin Giles:

Hey All,

Wondering if anyone has seen this out there in the last month or if anyone has a referral of any banks currently offering this loan option?

 @Benjamin Giles    Any conventional lender should be able to do it. HOWEVER, your upfront fees will be hefty thanks to the loan level price adjustments (LLPA) on a 90% second home. LLPA's are more or less how much over a par rate. So, for 10% second home there is a 4.125% in negative adjustments.  

Fannie Mae LLPA matrix


 Thanks Jay! That was super helpful. So If I understand this I would be looking at base rate +4.125 then whatever additional rate the lender is adding on, minus points to buy the rate down?  I was expecting (hoping for) 8% so I'm probably going to be closer to 10% unless I buy full 2 points?

Hey All,

Wondering if anyone has seen this out there in the last month or if anyone has a referral of any banks currently offering this loan option?

Quote from @Jessie Dillon:

it sounds like you are renting it out right now against the HOA's owner-occupied rules. so first and foremost, i'd consider not renewing the current tenant, and selling when the unit is vacant. do you really want to be in a position where the HOA finds out & either hits you with a huge fine OR makes you violate landlord/tenant laws and kick the tenant out mid-lease?


 All current investor owners were grandfathered in. They are only set on not allowing new investors to come in. Area is a very low grade market.

Tenant is out of lease and on a month to month.

I'm not really interested in selling it just was wondering if there was ANY benefit to having it in my LLC vs personally owning other than moving liability

Quote from @Bill B.:

You say a refi doesn't make sense because of the high interest rates. And then you mention wanting a DSCR loan which will be even higher interest rate? Explain.

What's the upside you're trying to get to with the LLC? It won't limit liability. It won't add any meaningful privacy. It will make future loans harder and more expensive.

Start with what you’re tying to accomplish by doing this.

You also probably want to look in to what the HOA really did to their rules. I'm 99% sure they didn't say "can't be sold to an investor". That's as easy to get around as I'm buying it as my primary in cash. A month later, I don't like this place, I'm going to rent it out. More likely there's a limit on how many units can be rentals which won't affect you or your buyer. There's a 90% chance your buyer, especially the one offering the most will be an owner occupant. And if he/she isn't then there's a 99% chance they could buy a rental with an existing lease they can't legally break, and be just fine.

In the bylaws they reduced the number of units that can be rented or sublet to 25%. There are currently 65% rented or sublet. 

The low ARV of the unit ~100k will not work with a refi from attempts so far as I have been shopping it for a year with around 12-15 different lenders, the fees are too high of a percentage of the total loan and won't meet fannie/freddie requirments, and other than private money I have not found a lender who will refi at such a low loan price (~75k loan) without charging dispraportionate fees to originate and APR.

The DSCR loan would be on a future property not on this property, and I have heard mention in forums, podcasts, and other conversations that often times lenders providing DSCR will look at subjective factors on a deal like assets, portfolio, and other common sense lending factors when doing the underwriting. I was curious if anyone had experienced this or if any lenders could vouch for that when lending to your LLC. 

I am not concerned with liability or privacy, my goal I suppose is to have the income on my LLC balance sheet allowing me to season the LLC and establish credit in order to purchase future properties under the LLC rather than purchasing them personally, and get access to a wider variety of loan products.