My house has almost doubled in value in the last 5 years. Mostly because I bought it as a foreclosure and fixed it up myself while living there. If I were to rent it out now I would have about a $800 per month cash flow.
If I were to buy my home in today's market and rent it (assuming I would be on the renter's list), my cash flow would be around $150. I bought it with 5% down conventional at 3.25% interest and put about $25k into fixing it up. I also paid the PMI up front, so my monthly payment is very low, about half its rental potential. I would like to keep it if possible.
If I can get on the renter's list now I will be on it forever as long as its rented. If a tenant ever leaves, I have 30 days to find a new tenant and submit the paperwork for HOA board approval. This is why it takes so long to be able to rent. A homeowner would have to sell their rental unit to free up a space. Or a homeowner would have to move back into their rental unit and request to be removed from the renter's list, which would probably not happen. I didn't know these rules until after I moved in, my fault. This is my first and last time buying into an HOA ran community.
What gets me is that a lot of people rent without being on the rent's list and hope they don't get caught. This has been brought up to the HOA's attention but they just sit on it like other issues. I am trying to do things the correct way.