Thanks Joel & Emilio- those are definitely great options.
The building was built in 1911 - and it's an older Victorian home that was turned into 3 units back in the 1970's. It's not set up in a way that condos would work without some major renovations. I hadn't previously thought about breaking them off as condos to sell - but I don't see it working on this property. When I bought the triplex it rented for $450 more than I can get out of it now and I only intended to flip it for a quick small gain. Oh the regrets!
I cannot qualify to buy anything additional. I have great credit as of now but I am maxed out on lending. I am the only person on the loan though so I will look into whether or not my husband could purchase something that could help even out the losses - I'm not sure what the requirements would be to purchase a rental property with current lending policies? How much down? ...I'll look into that.
The home we live in does not have any equity either in this market. We could probably eat our losses on that and sell for what we owe and rent something cheaper or move into one of the triplex units - which we've seriously been considering (although living in a 600 square foot rental in college-town is making me claustrophic already). It all comes back to how long I'm going to be bleeding money on it though. I've lost $40k on it so far - if I keep floating it even for another 5 years that's another $25-30k down the drain. The amount of time it'll take to recoup those losses in property values/rents increasing is daunting. I realize this was NOT a smart investment- especially after your breakdown of the 50%. But it was my responsibility and I feel as though I need to do whatever I have to in order to make it work but maybe my morals aren't as strong as I thought because here I am debating if I should give it up.
Oh and my insurance will only cover the damage caused by the emergency repair - but not the repair itself which is 90% of the cost.
Thanks again for your thoughts! I appreciate the options.