Thank you everyone for your responses. They will help us as we decide whether or not to pursue this property.
I am considering this property for these reasons:
1. It is highly competitive in California and decent properties in good areas are going for prices that don't cash flow. If overpaying, there is the risk that the market is near peaking and the financials on the property will tank in the next few years. Sometimes taking a distressed property and fixing the problems is the only way in.
2. Some section 8 people are good, but circumstances mean they cannot support themselves entirely. Because my daughter has Down Syndrome (the third person in our picture), some of her adult friends live in Section 8 housing. They are dependable tenants and sweet people, so being section 8 alone is not enough to say no to a property or tenant. I would want to ensure the building is secure and safe enough for such tenants (still trying to find that out) Being destructive or dangerous is another story. That kind of section 8 person I would want to avoid.
California is very tenant friendly, so kicking someone out is not easy or cheap. The owner is preparing disclosures, so I will keep you posted when I learn more.
3. The area is growing and the property is only a few blocks from downtown with restaurants and amenities. Downtown and shopping areas tend to have higher crime statistics because of things like shop lifting. Downtown SF has very high per capital crime rates because of the high transient population (visitors) vs the actual residents included in the per capita statistics, so I feel perfectly safe walking through there. I am trying to find out if that is the case here vs being the area that attracts drugs, vandals, and the like. Also I am trying to find out if the area is improving or worsening. Does anyone have ideas on how to find such things out?
I would appreciate knowing if someone had a similarly destructive tenant and how they were able to handle it in case we do move forward and have to deal with the tenant. Hopefully the coming disclosure will better illuminate the story of this tenant.