Aloha All,
This is a very late reply for all the help that was given by the members above. But if someone gets into this situation, I want them to know how it was handled And they can message me anytime for tips.
So, I did let the county know that I received their letter of the $1000 a day fine for vacation renting and informed them of my issue (owning the unit, but Tentant illegally subletting unit for vacation rental unbeknownst to me).
Maui County was understanding and the landlord tenant hotline (free) we have here gave me some tips for eviction procedures.
Note: The hotline in Hawaii is awesome. Yes, they may be a bit bias towards the tenant a lot of the time, but the employees were livid about my tenant Vacation renting the unit when we have an affordable housing shortage.
My tenant did have several more vacation renters in the unit after I gave her the eviction, but she did agree to leave after the 45 days.
The place was trashed, so I did keep her deposit, which didn’t cover all the damage done to the unit. But, in Hawaii, you are not intitled to the deposit for the gross breach of contact alone as some friends thought.
I assume this does and will continue to happen to many landlords because the money is so good in Vacation renting units here. Make sure your contacts are solid against sublet/vacation renting and know that you have me as a resource if needed.
I could write another 1000 words on the back and forth between the tenant and myself, but I’ll save you the details unless you find yourself in the same situation.
Mahalo, Rob