Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Ayanna Donovan

Ayanna Donovan has started 3 posts and replied 9 times.

Quote from @Stuart Udis:

@Ayanna Donovan I can certainly understand your frustrations. It’s unfortunate so much time was lost determining a use permit was not appropriate and a variance was required but everything that’s transpired since your May 2024 zoning hearing adds up and shouldn’t be viewed as a concern. Just so you’re aware, it can take up to 3-4 weeks to obtain your notice of decision after the ZBA hearing and the 30 day appeal period doesn’t begin until the notice of decision is issued so you can easily wait 60 days from the date of your hearing to receive a copy of your zoning permit. 

Expect multiple rounds of comments from L&I and don’t expect the first list of comments recieved to be the final list either. That’s why it’s best to pay the additional fee for accelerated review. It can greatly cut down on the review periods. It’s also up to the architect to address the comments and resubmit the plans efficiently. 

Next time consider implementing better contingencies into your agreement. It’s particularly important in Philadelphia where there’s a ton of ambiguity in permitting, particularly use permits. 

@Stuart Udis Unfortunately I'm unable to expedite it now since I already submitted the application. The only alternative would be to withdraw it, which I don't believe makes any sense at this point.

During my meeting with L&I, I learned that the application will continue to be sent back for revisions each time an issue is found, without full review upfront. This approach is seems so wrong and has discouraged me from expanding my portfolio in Philly.

That said, I appreciate all the feedback that you've provided and will take this as and will take this as a learning experience moving forward.

Quote from @Dominique “Dom“ Leal:

Hey Ayanna,

I hear you loud and clear... dealing with city permits can feel like running a marathon with hurdles you didn't see coming. I had a client in Philly who went through a similar ordeal. Every time we thought we had all the boxes checked, the city threw another curveball our way.

One thing that eventually helped was getting in touch with someone directly in the zoning office. Sometimes a face-to-face conversation can cut through the red tape faster than any paperwork shuffle.

It might feel like the city's operating without accountability, but there are folks within the system who genuinely want to help - you just have to find them. Don't loose hope; once you get past this bump, it'll be worth the hassle.

If you ever want to chat more about strategies or just vent over a coffe, I'm here. Hang in there!

Jasper & Dom

Maximizing Austin & San Antonio Investors' ROI - Investing in Two of America's Fastest-Growing Markets


I really appreciate the feedback. Sometimes it feels like no one cares and it's not a priority to them. I've had this property for 2 years and I am still in the same place. Hopefully something will change soon, I am going to meet with L&I again next week.
Quote from @Stuart Udis:

@Ayanna Donovan The way you describe the process is off and that's probably the reason why you are having so much difficulty. If you received a variance, once the notice of decision was posted and appeal period ran its course you should have first obtained your zoning permit. You can't jump ahead to the building permit until the ZP is issued. You say the contractor is resubmitting the revisions but where is the architect and what role is he/she playing? It sounds like this is a building permit application that requires plans which means you will need an AIA to seal the drawings. 

If this is happening and was merely left out of your post are you certain this architect is knowledgeable about the local code and permitting process?  The architect should also be the one making the submissions through the eclipse system. The contractor doesn't have to be named and associated with the permit until the billing statement is ready for issue. Also are their overlays that require pre-reviews by other city agencies? This can delay the process because they must approve the plans through the eclipse system before the plans examiner can review and each time the plans are resubmitted the plans first must go through any pre-requisite review agency which can add lots of time. Just dealt with this for a project that required pre-review by both historical commission and city planning commission...took 3 months of submissions before the plans even got to the L&I plans examiner for the first time. 

 Also, always best to accelerate drawings in Philly. When accelerated your reviews are completed in  business 10 days which adds up especially since you rarely obtain a billing statement without at least one round of comments and normally multiple are required. Unfortunately the additional fee disproportionately impacts smaller projects (I recently paid the same acceleration fee for  $600,000 SF renovation as I just did for a $2.5M school building conversion). 


I apologize for leaving a few details out. I bought the property in 2022 believing that it was properly zoned for a restaurant on the first floor and a single unit above. However, the City took a very
strict interpretation of the code and ruled that the permits obtained by the prior owner (the seller) were expired. My lawyer tried to challenge the interpretation (with an appeal) but was not successful and we had to obtain the zoning approval for a second time. I was finally able to obtain the zoning permit after attending a new hearing before the ZBA in May 2024 and the received the documentation in July (I also don't understand why it took two months to receive the paperwork).

My architect is the one who has been submitting all the permit applications, including the initial permit which is how we found out the zoning was expired. When he went to reapply (after we received the zoning permit) the application was no longer found within the eclipse system and we had to submit a new application. We submitted the application in August and received an update in September with revisions, my architect met with the examiner to confirm those revisions. We submitted a another application with those revisions and it was due back October 17th. Now the examiner is saying there are more revisions that need to be made that were not brought up the first time.

Quote from @Chris Seveney:
Quote from @Ayanna Donovan:

Has anyone else experienced delays with L&L? I've owned my property for nearly a year and a half, and obtaining zoning and building permits has been a nightmare. Once my zoning variance was granted, I expected getting the building permit would be straightforward. However, every time my contractor submits the applications, the city requests new revisions. The review process for each submission takes about a month, which further delays progress.

 Is there anyone I can escalate this issue to? It feels like the city can operate without accountability.


 Are you using qualified consultants or did you go with the cheapest? Getting permits after a variance depending on jurisdiction for multifamily for projects I have done has typically been 6-18 months. (those were 200+ units). What types of comments are they providing that require revisions? Has your team sat down with them in advance or recently to go through everything as well ? Lots of ways to quicken this process but the best way is to have a team that knows what they are doing.


When you say "qualified consultants" who are you referring to ? The architect and contractor? It seems like every time we submit the application the city comes up with new revisions that were not previously mentioned. We met with examiner prior to submitting the application with updated revisions, now there are more comments that the examiner never brought up the first time.

Has anyone else experienced delays with L&L? I've owned my property for nearly a year and a half, and obtaining zoning and building permits has been a nightmare. Once my zoning variance was granted, I expected getting the building permit would be straightforward. However, every time my contractor submits the applications, the city requests new revisions. The review process for each submission takes about a month, which further delays progress.

 Is there anyone I can escalate this issue to? It feels like the city can operate without accountability.

I purchased a mixed-use property in Philadelphia that came with brand new restaurant equipment. I am currently looking for a commercial tenant that is interested in opening up a take out restaurant. Any advice on how I can find potential tenants would be appreciated. 

Multifamily- restaurant on the bottom with an apartment on top. 

Hello,

I am looking for a commercial broker in Philadelphia. Please let me know of any you recommend.