Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Brian Crutchfield

Brian Crutchfield has started 2 posts and replied 5 times.

Originally posted by @Brie Schmidt:

@Brian Crutchfield - Do those mortgage amounts include taxes, insurance, HOA fees?

You are right, they create 2 very different calculations. I would say 75% of banks underwrite it based on how I explained it. I have only run into a bank once that added net rents to my income and then the total PITI payment to my debt ratio, and I immediately found a new bank cause there is no way that would work out for me

Yes, those are PITIA amounts. 

SFR is on a 3% ARM, 30 year am. Taxes are $1,157/yr. Insurance is $586/yr. $819.19 payment.

SFR also has a HELOC with a current payment of around $75.

Duplex is on a 3.75% ARM, 30 year am. Taxes are $997/yr. Insurance is $706/yr. $841 payment.

If this is correct, then we are nowhere near that 50% DTI. That could be a game changer. I will be talking with lenders in the coming months. Thanks for the input.

Originally posted by @Brie Schmidt:

@Brian Crutchfield

1. It is a fannie/freddie requirement, so basically impossible to get around. 

2. Yes, they will use the current income or projected income from the new property to help you qualify.  They will use 75% of gross rents on stuff you own and new stuff until you do your taxes on what you own already.  

So on the SFH they will count $1181 of rent minus the mortgage payment (my guess is $1300) so that will show a negative monthly income of $119

On the duplex they will use $1575 of rent minus the mortgage payment (my guess is $1425) so that will show a positive monthly income of $150

So in the end, you will show $31 of monthly rental income.

Add that to your current monthly income

Add in 75% of the rent from half the duplex on the property you are getting

And that will be the basis they will determine your DTI on.

If I am buying in A/B areas I find that my taxes reflect more income than the 75% of gross rents.  Here is a calculator my bank gave me on how they determine rental income based off my tax return

https://www.biggerpockets.com/files/user/chicagobr...

Brie, thanks for the response. 

So just to be sure I have this correctly, and to adjust some of your numbers to the actual amounts:

SFR:

Rent = $1,575

x 75% = $1,181

- Mortgage of $892 = $289

Duplex:

Rent = $2,150

x 75% = 1,613

- Mortgage of $841 = $772

Total to add to salary for DTI = $1,061

So the "net rental income" after subtracting mortgage payments is added to income? I was under the impression that the rent (x 75%) was added to income and the existing mortgages were added to debt. This creates 2 completely different calculations. Does it depend on whether it is another investment property vs. a personal residence? Just to clarify, we will be occupying this next home.

Hi all. I posted this question in another post, but it seems I kind of "buried the lead" in a long post with details on my current situation, and no one felt like reading all the way to the end!

Quick background:

My wife and I are fairly new to REI. We moved out of our SFR and rented it out. We are currently "house hacking" a duplex. We plan to move out next March or so, and into a new SFR. If you're interested in the full background, check out this post:

https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/12/topics/347...

My questions are:

1. How are people getting around DTI requirements once you start to own multiple properties? Will any lenders go to 50% these days?

2. Will lenders use rental income if leases are in place, without years of tax returns? I'm also reading that the rule of thumb is to use 75% of rental income to qualify for the next mortgage. Is this fairly standard practice?

Thanks to anyone who can provide any assistance. Also, any advice on what we have done so far (see linked post) is welcomed.

Originally posted by @Luke G.:

Free bump for you as I am also curious to see what others might have for answers. Best of luck to you moving forward.

Thanks! I see you are moving to our area. It's a tough market to enter at the moment, but I'm of the belief that there are always deals to be had if you keep your eyes and your mind open. Best of luck to you as well.

Hello BP. I am a new investor in the Asheville, NC area. I've been lurking/reading for quite some time and have finally decided to post. Sorry for the lengthy post, but I thought I'd provide some background info before I get to my question.

A little background: My wife and I (and our toddler and newborn) have just started our REI journey this past March. I am currently working on finishing the CPA exam (1 test down, 3 to go) and working for a small CPA firm, and she stays at home with the 2 kids. She has a decent amount of experience in the construction industry as a project estimator, and has also done a fair amount of small rehab work herself. We figured we are a perfect match for the REI world, coming at it from those 2 different sectors. Knowing the ins and outs of the numbers and tax consequences of owning real estate, as well as the realities of rehabbing and the construction industry in general will no doubt set us up to be successful if we continue to work hard towards our goals.

So far: We moved out of our personal residence (SFR) in March of this year, and purchased and moved into a duplex on the other side of town. Purchase price was $167,500 and we are currently renting out the other side for $1,050/month. Once we are able to move out, we are looking at hopefully at least another $1,050/month for the side we currently occupy, making this about a 1.25% (gross rents/purchase price) deal (not bad for our market). We have upgraded this property a decent amount from an aesthetics and general cleanliness standpoint, and put about $7,000 of work into it to begin with (new countertops, a few appliances, new carpet, paint, and tree removal). Several investors have come in to purchase other homes (street has several other duplexes) on the street and have improved these properties as well. I have no doubt that we have earned some equity here. Financing was 90% LTV through a local credit union.

The SFR that we moved out of was NOT purchased with REI in mind and I would purchase it totally different today than I did then, BUT here are the numbers: Purchase price was $202,900 and it is currently renting for $1,575/month. Not a great deal on paper, but we are currently cash flowing a small amount. Home will require a full HVAC upgrade this fall, but several other big items have already been replaced or were upgraded/replaced by the previous owner. We financed this home at 80% LTV through a local bank (here is where I would have saved my capital and gone with FHA or another low money down strategy had I had the foresight, but alas, "it is what it is" as they say).

My plan is to eventually use 1031 to trade up to 8+ unit buildings, then parlay that into either apartments, mixed use, or commercial down the line.

Going forward: House hacking the duplex is clearly not the ideal situation with a toddler and a newborn. We would like to move out by next year once we have satisfied the loan's owner occupancy requirement, and purchase our personal residence that we would like to stay in for several years before we are able to build our dream home. We know that once we move out, our rents will increase with the other unit opening up. The problem is that when I run the numbers for DTI (even using the rental income @75%), we are coming up short of what we would like to be able to qualify for. My question is how are people getting around DTI requirements when you start to own multiple properties? I will be speaking to lenders in the coming months as we move forward, but I'd like to get an idea of what people are doing to circumvent DTI issues. Any other advice on any of the other info is also welcomed. Thanks.