@Joel, the building is the one with the block screen wall. I show the other buildings and Route 66 for context.
I think you make great points. Seller financing usually accounts for a greater sales price, but not this extreme. My agent pulled comps and they didn't even want to look at them. It was as if the number was pulled from the hat.
I agree with you and Rich that my downpayment was too low too, but again, I thought we could negotiate. I think she thinks she can rent it for 10$ psf but the comps in the 'hood are $6.50 (asking). Another problem is that her agent owns the building next door, and has overestimated the value and pumped up her expectations. She just fired this agent by the way, and they took the for sale sign down.
@Rich, I'm sure I upset her with the offer amount despite the fact that it matches the comps. I did have a contractor visit the building and give me a bid to make the necessary repairs (roof, all floors, elec., ceilings) and his bid was $70k. By the way, I used a 20 yr amortization and a 10 yr call. My accountant thought that 5% would be attractive to them since they would prob. not do a 1031 and the banks aren't paying but 1% interest. This may have been a misstep too.
My next plan is to meet with her face to face, one on one and see what she wants in terms of monthly income. I think I can up my downpayment to about $25k. What do you suggest in this case where her asking price does not match the comps? And her rent expectation is totally unrealistic without major improvements?
Thanks,
M