So take this all with a grain of salt. I've been with them for over 2 years. And I would have highly recommended them up until September of last year when their company went through a major restructure. One that involved firing their entire field operations team, which I thought was key to their success. If you're new to them, you'll probably have a better experience. Because you won't know anything different. But I remember when they weren't so automated and you could actually call someone to talk through issues.
This new structure has come with many many headaches for me, the prime one being there was absolutely zero communication with owners like me about the change. I called my field ops person one day to ask why a tenant wasn't given a key for move in day and was told he had no idea because he was let go during the restructure. And still almost 4 month since then, I have asked Nomad numerous times for anything that would help me understand the new tiers and how its different from previous division of responsibilities.
I get things piecemeal here and there, like all of a sudden after 2 years I'm responsible for placing lockbox, surprise! I had to run out and buy new lockboxes to place in time for showings. And don't even get me started on utilities. They have an option to do a flat fee for utilities which I opted in on, and yet the automated system still sent out an email to tenants to get utilities in their name. Talk about unnecessary confusion for me and for the tenants to undo the mess.
And I'm not sure where you're getting the 4% from. They charge me 7% for the basic guaranteed rent service (along with the listing fee) and then if they do manage any of the tenant work orders there is an additional fee on top of that because I only signed up at the lowest level where owners manage work orders.
So again, if you sign up new with them you'll probably have a better experience. I'm getting annoyed all over again because I'm paying a higher percentage and getting way less service than I had before. They're all nice people at the company, I just think they're going through major growing pains and unfortunately old owners are feeling the brunt of it.