Thanks so much for the input, tough love, etc.
Here are some additional details:
- This is our second investment property. The other is an LTR that cashflows 300/mo
- Loan amt: 348K (bought for 490K and put about 30% down)
- Current value: 490K
- Home value post-reno: $685ish. Comps with no pool have sold for $665.
- STR projected monthly net income (before taxes): $1700/mo. (with $200K in reno. Estimated 4.5 years to recoup the 200K)
- LTR projected monthly net income (before taxes): $611/mo. (with $60K in reno. Estimated 11.7 years to recoup the 60K)
- Disposable income, roughly $2600/mo. which gives me peace of mind in terms of covering the mortgage and the $60K if we do the smaller reno for the LTR. But does fall short (by about $800) of covering both the mortgage AND the loan for $200K (if we decide to go 'Full Monty Renovation' and make it a STR with pool, etc.). The 200K is money borrowed off the value of another property @4.5% for 20 years. So that's why I'm leaning a bit toward LTR even though I will get more cash from STR. I don't want to be overextended. But I also want to maximize cash flow so we can buy another property soon!
This is all pretty new to me and I'd love input from other investors. Thanks again!!