All Forum Posts by: Angela Clark

I wouldn't ask for a doctor note. That would be a horrible thing on her part to lie about. The fact that the tree was in bad shape may put you on the hook for the repair. I think knowing more of the story makes me lean toward at least helping with some of the cost. Depends on how you want her to view you as a landlord and if you are willing to lose/replace a tenant. Good luck this one is a moral and ethical dilemma. I would still make an addendum to the lease stating that going forward you are in no way responsible for any damages to or resulting from tenants personal property.

I can't help but notice this thread really has nothing to do with your real estate property but has everything to do with two people who don't see eye to eye and clearly don't work well together. As I read each one of your posts I kept feeling like I was supposed to read between the lines and call 911 for you. I hope you are okay. 

Curious

If the trampoline didn't come with the property then the responsibility falls on the tenant to replace. This is why she should be carrying renters insurance. I guess offer to help with the cost if you really want to keep the peace but like another poster pointed out, in most states a tree falling is considered an act of God and wouldn't be covered under your insurance unless the tree was rotten or neglected and was a hazard to the property in general. I would definitely make an addendum to future leases prohibiting trampolines.