@Brett Sorenson
The lender usually dictates which type
Of coverage you are allowed to have. i.e. replacement cost vs cash value. They want their asset protected and usually require replacement cost.
On the flip side the insurance company doesn’t care if you have a mortgage or whether you own it free and clear or if your grandmother gave it to you. They are not an investment hedge. They are simply there to repair what was lost should you have a claim. They are also a for profit enterprise and make more money if they charge you for replacement cost vs actual cash value.
The reality is you are way more likely to have a partial loss than a total loss. And the lender doesn’t want to guess whether you have the money to fix any possible loss at that exact moment. So they require replacement cost.
There are many many insurance carriers out there who will insure this property. Some are better at it from a pricing perspective than others. Best thing to do is shop around.
Happy to answer any other questions you or anyone else may have.
Andrew Wicklow