Thank you all for the responses!
@John Woodrich Good point on the absolute value of cash flow rather than COC. I think I was focusing more on the COC potential before. And I certainly don't know enough about areas within the markets, at least yet. More to look into!
@David Moore Glad to hear a success story! A few people have mentioned potential resale issues which I need to spend more time analyzing. Yeah, real estate in Crystal has gone way up the last few years! We bought our first house in Crystal back in 2012 and just sold it this spring. Considered keeping it as a SFR but we needed the equity to fund a major renovation on the new place in Plymouth.
@Ryan Tuleja Thanks for the comment. Contractors have been mentioned a few times so I can see how important that part of the plan would be.
@Isaac Braun Thanks for the feedback, if we consider St. Cloud more seriously I may have to ping you about areas to avoid if you're open to that.
@Jordan Moorhead Great point. I think maybe I discounted looking around the metro because of the price appreciation over the last few years, but it sounds like the consensus is there's still value to be found around here. Now I just need to get my wife to move from considering investing to actually purchasing a property! :-)