Hey @Victoria C. & All -
Wow - I'm a bit surprised at how polar the responses have been in opposition to the AirBnB. I tend to think that the AirBnb exposes you to certain liabilities as mentioned in previous comments but this could be resolved with an addendum to the existing lease agreements.
Ultimately, being that they had already (successfully) operated their AirBnb business without harm to your home (AirBnb's obviously must be kept in much better condition than a personal residence). The ABnb income indirectly benefits you in providing a long-term tenant with a consistent source of income to pay you rent.
My opinion would be:
- Mention to the residents that they broke the lease but you understand. Agree to sign an addendum to prevent exposure to liability
- Continue to allow them to do this under the belief that the home is kept in good shape (only you could determine this)
- Continue you increase rents in accordance with the market (these increases don't have a significant impact of a business' bottom line whereas a traditional, long-term tenant would freak).
This ultimately becomes a partnership between yourself and the tenant without the direct compensation. In all honesty, I wish my tenants were savvy and found ways to hack their rents like this.
Curious to hear everyone's thoughts?