@Devan Mcclish, the unit is a 4 plex. The units are separated for electricity, but it has a separate meter for outdoor security lighting and indoor hallway lighting which I see as a very good thing as in Massachusetts the Tenant/Landlord laws are incredibly strict and tenants paying for common space utilities is a big no no. The heating is partially separate. The largest unit, 3BR 2Bath, is completely separate and paid by the tenant, but the three 1BR units are owner paid and we would be in one of them, but they have a very new efficient gas heater which is by far the cheapest heating source up in our area. That is where most of that cost comes from, so it is not as bad as you thought.
As for the cap rate, as you can tell by the price, Massachusetts is pretty expensive and the properties that might produce a higher cap rate are in an area I can't commute to work from and this is the best I have found in our commutable radius thus far. Even though its technically negative cash flow with me paying nothing, I would be paying way less than my current rent, so its additional money in my pocket every month.
Thank you for your input!