Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Amy Lee

Amy Lee has started 9 posts and replied 21 times.

Yes you're right. Numbers and market analysis. Thanks Jaron!

Quote from @Jaron Walling:

@Amy Lee The plan you described is full of holes and challenges but yes you're on track. At the most basic level your #1 goal should be buying distressed as low as possible, maximizing every dollar you have for the rehab, and getting a strong appraisal. "Hoping the reno added equity and I have at least 20%" - You can't hope anything... you need to know the market numbers (ARV, rehab budget, etc.). Without this information you can't refinance and make the strategy work in your favor. I wouldn't even waste your time. SFH, duplex, tri, it doesn't matter. Every property has a market value when it's shiny and "new". Know these numbers before you make offers.

When I started out I did something similar. 3% down, conventional loan, distressed, bought off the MLS. It was a live-in flip and I house-hacked with my brother. It was a win-win. Rehab budget was $20k. I blew $9k on the roof! We learned a lot, increased the property value, used some hammers, vetted and hired contractors, and after a 6 month seasoning period I refinanced the property. That was in my entry into homeownership.

If I can do if you can too. Follow the numbers not your emotions! Cheers. 


Hi everyone. Thank you in advance for all your advice. I love the people here.

I was initially looking to househack a duplex with FHA but the MLS market isn't very active for the area I'm looking at. At this rate, I may run into finding a property in the winter time (or 2024) and having difficulties finding a tenant as well as someone to take over my lease (im at month 4 of a 15 lease).

I wanted to consider a live in BRRRR strategy where I find a distressed property on MLS with a 5% down conventional. Im not sure if sellers on the off market/wholesale side would be inclined to take a conventional loan offer vs a cash offer, thus MLS is what I was looking at. I would use a credit card or home depot project loan to cover all the reno costs. Hoping the reno added equity and I have at least 20%, I would cash out refi to pay off the rehab costs and use the remaining funds for an investment property going into the brrrr cycle. The initial property, I would live in for about 2-3 years as a primary.

Does this make sense to you guys or am I patching up plans that are weird...

Post: Shopping rates FHA

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10
Quote from @Jason Wray:

Amy,

FHA is only good if you need to put less than 5% down and have less than perfect credit. If you can afford to put 5% down avoid FHA if you have a credit score above 680. FHA caters to those who need to put less down (3.5%) or have lower credit scores (580 to 699) or have lower income where it causes you to have a higher back end ratio usually above 49% and less PITI reserves. If you have to go FHA you need to choose a Big bank one that is Fully Delegated which means has little to no overlays. FHA is the exception if you want to buy a 2-4 Unit as a primary because its only 3.5% so there is a benefit on that scenario.

Most Lenders/Brokers charge points or have to hit their "loan officer compensation plan" AKA bucket. That means they get paid a percentage or "commission" and have to charge a higher rate to get paid. When you work with an FDIC Bank or Credit Union they are not allowed to charge points on Ginnie Mae/FHA/VA/USDA loans. You also do not want to have multiple lenders/brokers pulling your credit you want to narrow it down to (2) options.

There is also "No haggling" with a true bank or credit union fees are set based on fair lending standards. If a lender or broker cuts costs or fee's that means they are breaking the rules and overpriced. When most lenders offer a "Quote" they cannot actually offer you a true rate quote unless you ask for a 30-60 day Locked LE "loan estimate". That would require a full application and a credit pull but it’s a "Locked offer".

If you are not getting a "locked LE" your basically window shopping or getting a "teaser rate" which means the loan officer/broker is giving you the 5 "Day close rate". You cannot close on a day rate meaning close in 5 days. Bankers, Lenders, brokers can see what is known as the 5 day rate which means if someone wants to float and lock 5 days out from closing they can get the lower or best rate.  That 5 day rate is used a lot to offer teaser quotes instead of the actual 30 day lock rate pricing.

Avoid anyone who works at a call center, does not have a team and does not pick up your calls after hours or weekends! Banker hours are for people who are not devoted to their agents and customers.

Hi Jason.  Wow. Thank you for your reply! I should've mentioned that it is for a multifamily property in which I do not have enough for a 15% down on a conventional. Also this rate shopping was prior to having any kind of offer or property in mind. It was literally just to see what the going rate was at that time. Real Estate is confusing. Someone told me to avoid large banks but it appears that they usually have better rates since they cant add to the interest to make their commission. I learn a lot on BiggerPockets!

Post: Shopping rates FHA

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10

Hi, I was "shopping" for rates because someone advised me that is the way to go. Now I'm realizing it doesn't make sense. I don't get locked into any rate so the rate I shopped 2 weeks ago is not the rate I would get today. Also, I am hearing that FHA rates are pretty similar between individuals at the higher credit scores and varies little. Am I not seeing something about shopping rates on FHA?

Post: Specifically- How to shop for an FHA lender

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10
Quote from @John Warren:

@Matthew Hetrick the thing to keep in mind is that you aren't really shopping for anything special on the loan itself. Pretty much all lenders can do the same loans generally speaking with FHA. Instead, you are looking for a lender who knows investing and who understands all the ways to make your deal a winner. As a realtor, I have an amazing lender that I both use personally and who I refer to clients. I always cringe when the clients end up with some major bank because I know the lender on the other end making $20 an hour will have no idea how to get the deal done if it gets complicated.

One thing you can do is ask the lender about self sufficiency for 3 and 4 units. If their eyes glaze over then they don't know anything about house hacking with an FHA loan. Also, ask them if you can use a 5% down conventional to buy a 3 or 4 unit. This was possible last year, but is 99% impossible now due to recent changes but I still run into lenders who don't know about those changes.


 I came across your answer while researching something for myself. This absolutely answered everything and cleared up something I had doubts on. thank you!

Post: FHA owner occupancy

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10
Quote from @Josh Bowser:

Hey @Amy Lee - you should check with the property manager of your apartment complex as there should be a way to buyout your remaining lease. TYPICALLY, you need to give a certain amount of notice and pay a certain portion of the remaining lease. 

With an FHA 203k you should be able to live in another dwelling as the renovation is being completed, but you will need to talk with your lender / mortgage broker to figure out what that would look like as it will likely vary depending on scope of work!


 Hey Josh. I checked my lease and it's one of those "you are responsible until someone else moves in". With fall/winter around the corner, tenants might not be in our favor.

Post: FHA owner occupancy

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10
Quote from @Brittany Minocchi:

You mentioned renovations - are you planning on an FHA 203(k) or a "regular" FHA? They are very different.


Hi Brittany. Sorry for the confusion. I'm looking at the FHA 203K.

Post: FHA owner occupancy

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10

Hello everyone,

I'm still in the learning process but is somewhat convinced now might be the time to pull the trigger. I have moved to this area just a couple weeks ago and signed a 15 month apartment lease. My concern is if I'm able to find a home to househack, I could potentially be paying double monthly payments if the apartment is not able to find a tenant or if I'm not able to find a tenant quick. I understand you should have an emergency fund to cover for unexpected maintenance or not having tenants and all that but is there some kind of clause on a FHA that allows the home owner to temporarily stay in a secondary home during the reno phase or something of that sort? Thank you so much for your expertise!

Post: FHA vs conventional loan

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10
Quote from @Andrew Postell:

@Amy Lee I need to provide some clarification on your post if you don't mind.

1. Downpayment - there is no 5% downpayment using a conventional loan with a 2-4 unit property.  A few years back there was, but there hasn't been that option for a while now.  So your options using a conventional loan are 15% down with a duplex as your own primary home and 20% down with a 2-4 unit property. 

2. FHA Rules - now FHA has this rule called the "self-sufficiency" rule on 3-4 units properties. This rule basically states that the rents have to be OVER the mortgage payment. And since rates are so high right now, and properties are so expensive, satisfying the "self-sufficiency" rule is next to impossible. And that means no FHA loans on 3-4 unit properties right now. This is an economic environment problem that will not always be around but be aware of this. Keep in mind that this does not apply on duplexes.

I know that was a lot but feel free to ask anything additional.  Thanks!


 I don't mind at all. Thank you for correcting and sharing information!!

Post: FHA vs conventional loan

Amy LeePosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 10

What would be the perks of using an FHA loan to househack on a multi family home (duplex-triplex)? There's the lower down payment but that makes your mortgage higher, you have to pay the the PMI (I forgot the term on FHA loans) for less than 20% down payment that lasts the life of the loan in my understanding, paperwork can be a lot I hear, and takes longer to close. So the only benefit is the lower down payment which you can do on a conventional loan also. Can someone educate me? Thank you!!