@Jeff Stein@Will Kenner@Jade S.
Thank you all for the helpful and insightful comments. I went for a second look yesterday with my agent and the listing broker, who is also the seller and got some more information. My agent is very knowledgable about the commercial space and I have a great deal of trust in him. He described the building as B- quality with very few A quality properties in town. The location is top notch.
The building was fully occupied pre-covid with a single tenant but that tenant vacated. The seller has put a few single tenants in there now, and it's probably 10% occupied. It seems like the seller is hoping to get an owner occupant cash buyer. Both the seller and my agent voiced the same concerns as you all about getting financing on a mostly vacant building and me only having experience in multi family and none in the commercial space. I do have a few investors that have lent to me in the past. The seller has a loan but is also willing to carry part of the purchase. I'd estimate she owes something in the $380-$400k range. It was purchased 6 years ago for $540k.
My agent believes they came to a list price by square footage. The seller had basically no financial info at the showing, so we've requested it. Thanks for the tip about the elevator costs.
Most likely, this building will end up being filled with gross leases. With multiple tenants, I'm told it would just be too complicated to do anything else.
My agent said expect it to take 12-18 months (conservatively) to fully occupy the building. It is taking longer to lease really large spaces but spaces in the 500-2500 sq ft range (like this space) is tending to get leased more quickly.
I totally understand the NOI driving the value of the property. The vacancy is why it hasn't sold and why I see opportunity in it. It's a deal that experienced investors probably wouldn't mess with but could be a learning experience for me. Having plenty of cash reserves would definitely be a priority, knowing it could be 18 months before it cash flows.
As for the market, it's across the street from the county government complex and a few blocks from the state capitol complex. The military base improvements are expected to be a huge driver for the town. Not many large employers in town. It's a small town but is growing.