@Ross Denman thanks so much for your reply! I should've clarified this is in Indianapolis, Wayne township, but I think Marion handles it?
It has definitely been a tough process. I'm just trying to better understand the timelines. I could not clearly find how long I would have to hold the tenants possessions, which I also think is pretty unfair to the landlord. I will have to check with an attorney just so I can better understand the process. I thought had read Indiana was a very landlord friendly state.
I agree that evictions should be left for worst case scenario as they are long-dragging and most expensive.
So for example, if the tenant has not paid by the 5th, you can serve a 10 day pay or quit notice? If they have not paid by the 16th, you can apply for a hearing and if you win, the judge may give the tenant 5-14 days to vacate? So there's a chance you can recoup your property by the end of the month?
As far as location, I feel my Realtor did a good job finding me the properties I wanted. They are nice units that are in a solid C area. I invested extra money to update the units, and I think they turned out pretty well. My PM also does a good job of pre-screening. 1 tenant was theirs, another was an inherited tenant. Probably just some bad luck to start my investor career in Indy. We have some good tenants in the other units. I just wasn't sure if these evictions were about average or worse than average. $10k is a big loss to me. I want to be able to be more pro-active when this happens again.
I also had another tenant voluntarily leave and she left the unit clean, and it was turned around and listed in less than a week.