Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Alexander Kostrubiec

Alexander Kostrubiec has started 4 posts and replied 12 times.

Post: Property management firm while living in one unit of a duplex?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1

@Kim Meredith Hampton Probably gonna go for a 4flat. I'm 22 and my girlfriend are moving out of our parents' places soon. The entire plan is to have an FHA loan to get 3.5% down on the unit, live in it for a year, then legally convert it to an investment property and move to get a quick easy investment property.

It makes sense that a duplex wouldn't be worth their time. I have no qualms against paying for my unit, as long as I'm still net positive cash flow.

Post: Property management firm while living in one unit of a duplex?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1

Hello.

I'm a Loan Officer and soon to be real estate agent, so I'm pretty handy with understanding the laws and nuances of these topics.

I've been wondering... If you live in a multi-unit property and rent out the other unit(s) which cover your PITI in full (with some net cash flow), you essentially do not need to pay rent, am I correct?

So, in the instance of hiring a property management firm to take care of retaining tenancy, repairs, etc... Is the 6% - 12% property management fee applied to your occupancy, even though you aren't paying rent? I am aware that the property management fee is 6% - 12% of the gross rent. Well, you're technically not having to pay any rent at all. So, are you going to get charged? Will your unit not receive any support in the event of damages, etc?

Thank you if you took the time to read my post, and hopefully this post will pique your interest, especially those of you who are into house hacking!

Post: How difficult to find a willing investor for a fix and flip?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1
Originally posted by @J Scott:
Originally posted by @Alexander Kostrubiec:

If you would answer this question, is the best way to build relationships with locals through investor/real estate meetups in your city? I'd love to go at some point.

That's a great way to meet successful investors, but not the best way to build relationships.  Building relationships takes time, and the best way to start doing that is to figure out how you can add value to those who you'd like to build relationships with.  People won't typically spend a lot of time helping a random stranger without any incentive -- so you need to provide that incentive.  Figure out how you can add value to their life/business and they will return the favor.

Again, thank you so much. As a young person/21 years old who really doesn't have that much experience in these matters, I feel that the best I could offer at this point would be my services as an MLO, or any capital for other investment ventures. I feel like I should gain a little more experience before I even attempt to do such a thing.

Because of my parents I have sort of an established relationship with some pretty successful people. A president of a brokerage firm, the former vice president of a brokerage firm, and a lot of agents/loan officers. I guess it's time to start reaching out lol.

Post: How difficult to find a willing investor for a fix and flip?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1
Originally posted by @J Scott:

I've financed a few deals for new rehabbers at 100% financing.  But, in every situation, it was someone I knew and trusted, and I was helping them get through their first deal -- so, I was also helping them analyze the deal and get through the deal (protecting both them and my money).

In other words, this was very much a mentor situation (free mentoring, just to be clear), where as part of mentoring the rehabber, I was also willing to lend the money because I knew they had a good education behind them.  I would never lend 100% to someone new who I didn't know, and I don't know anyone else who would either.

My recommendation is to build relationships with local investors who have been successful, and over time work towards convincing one of them to be your mentor.  If you can do this, that person is likely to be able to direct you to a private lender (and vouch for you), or perhaps even be willing to lend on the deal themselves.

Relationships are key in this business...

 That's some really great advice, thank you so much. I know a couple of people who would most likely consider doing investor financing (Maybe not 100% investor financing) with me, people who would respect me based on what I have achieved so far in the field. 

If you would answer this question, is the best way to build relationships with locals through investor/real estate meetups in your city? I'd love to go at some point.

Post: How difficult to find a willing investor for a fix and flip?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1
Originally posted by @Robin Wilk:

@Alexander Kostrubiec

Have you read The Book on Flipping Houses by J Scott or The Book on Investing in Real Estate with No (and Low) Money Down by Brandon Turner both of these are fantastic resources to get you started. I'm currently reading both of them simultaneously and they are providing me with a wealth of information. Check them out if you've got the time. 

 
I've picked up The Book on Investing in Real Estate with No (and Low) Money Down, a couple of chapters in, great material. Thanks for the other book recommendation, I'll have to read that one as well.

Post: How difficult to find a willing investor for a fix and flip?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

So you are looking for 100%. What protection does the investor have sense. You are not putting in money on the deal.

I'm aware that there are many options in terms of investor financing. From what I've studied, I see that 2+ investors are more common. This post is however regarding a single investor financing a fix and flip.

I'm not particularly looking for 100% financing, I'm just asking questions regarding the investor financing process. The 100% investor financing seems the most simple to me because the profits between you and the investor are split 50/50. Though, it is true that there would probably have to be a prior established relationship between you and the investor for such a large amount of capital.

Post: How difficult to find a willing investor for a fix and flip?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1

Hello everyone.

Throughout my studies I've discovered that it is possible to perform a fix and flip with no money on your part, as long as you do the work. What this apparently requires is for an individual to approach an investor that is willing to finance the costs, all the way up to 100% of the cost.

I assume that you could find people willing to invest with you through this community, or local Real Estate investment groups. I find this extremely surprising that an investor would be willing to contribute all the way up to 100% of the financing.

Anyone with any experience in these matters? Thank you :)

Post: Is it legal to airbnb a owner-occ unit in an owner-occ 4flat?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Alexander Kostrubiec:
Originally posted by @Kevin Romines:

As an ex-lender, I can advise you that lenders have ways of checking to see if your owner occupied? That said, most lenders don't, but get caught saying a property is owner occupied when its not and the most severe punishment is prosecution for loan fraud.

I understand your being anxious to do something as a vacation rental, but I would just ride out the 1 year as owner occupied and then from there, you wont have any issues. Heck, rinse repeat and do it all over again. Max out the number of properties most lenders will allow you to finance then tie the knot. You will have one huge leg up on your investments going into the marriage at that point. It's a thought?

Kudo's for thinking outside the box.......just don't cross lines that will make you regret things later?

 
I understand completely that misrepresenting a non-owner occ property as owner-occ is fraud for property and that mortgage fraud is severely punishable. I don't know what lenders would do to test for occupancy, ring your doorbell? I'd never want to cross any legal boundaries.

I'm not certain as to what the exact legal definition of occupancy is in terms of tenancy, but from my point of view, an occupancy would be something that included a leasing contract, payment of utilities, delivery of mail, tenant implements their own furnishings, etc. What if you took a week long vacation every month as the owner-occ, you know? It's quite murky.

The reasoning that the airbnb idea seems murky to me is that my girlfriend would be paying for utilities on her unit, she'd receive her mail at her unit, she'd furnish her own unit, legally it'd be her primary residency. If you airbnb'd your unit for a week to someone for 500$ for example there's no revolving lease contract or anything, that doesn't seem like occupancy to me, it seems like a smart move.

I'll definitely research a lot more into FHA's stance on occupancy, especially that 1 year occupancy piece of info that I see everybody mentioning around.

 For some reason, I can't understand exactly what the scenario is that you are proposing.

Would you mind breaking it down for me?

Where would the GF live?

Where would you live?

Which units and/or rooms would you rent for AirBnB?

I thought you were going to have a unit you'd use as AirBnB and then go live with your GF in her unit.

But, your last post talked about your GF not living in her unit.

So, are you saying that both of you would be buying owner occupied units and neither of you would live in either of them?

To get a straight answer, you really need to give a straight scenario.  

Maybe it's my age?  But, it seems like your questions go around in circles.

 I apologize if my questions seem difficult to follow, I'll respond to your questions in bulletpoint format to make it easier for anyone to follow.

  • Where would the GF live?
    With me, in my owner-occ unit within my 4flat. My unit would not be designated as her principal address.
  • Where would you live?
    In my owner-occ unit in my 4flat, which would be my principal address.
  • Which units and/or rooms would you rent for AirBnB?
    We would AirBnB rent the owner-occ unit in my girlfriends 4flat, which is her designated principal address.
  • I thought you were going to have a unit you'd use as AirBnB and then go live with your GF in her unit.
    The plan is that my gf and I are both going to take out FHA loans for the low 3.5% minimum downpayment on 4flats. My girlfriend will be living with me in my unit in my 4flat, but her designated unit in her 4flat would essentially be useless to her in terms of residency, since she is already living with me. There is no reason for us to be living apart, so the unit that belongs to her within her building would be essentially useless.

  • But, your last post talked about your GF not living in her unit.
    My gf would not be living in her owner occ unit per se. She would not have tenants within this unit, it is her designated unit.
  • So, are you saying that both of you would be buying owner occupied units and neither of you would live in either of them?
    We would both be purchasing separate owner-occ 4flats with FHA 3.5% minimum down. She would live with me in actuality in my owner-occ unit, but the owner-occ unit in her 4flat would be her principal address. We already live together.

    The reasoning for purchasing separate units in this manner is that an FHA 3.5% down on a unit uses a lot less capital than 20%+ down on a conventional mortgage on an investment property. We want to start investing as soon as possible, and this seemed like an interesting route.

Post: Is it legal to airbnb a owner-occ unit in an owner-occ 4flat?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1
Originally posted by @Kevin Romines:

As an ex-lender, I can advise you that lenders have ways of checking to see if your owner occupied? That said, most lenders don't, but get caught saying a property is owner occupied when its not and the most severe punishment is prosecution for loan fraud.

I understand your being anxious to do something as a vacation rental, but I would just ride out the 1 year as owner occupied and then from there, you wont have any issues. Heck, rinse repeat and do it all over again. Max out the number of properties most lenders will allow you to finance then tie the knot. You will have one huge leg up on your investments going into the marriage at that point. It's a thought?

Kudo's for thinking outside the box.......just don't cross lines that will make you regret things later?

 
I understand completely that misrepresenting a non-owner occ property as owner-occ is fraud for property and that mortgage fraud is severely punishable. I don't know what lenders would do to test for occupancy, ring your doorbell? I'd never want to cross any legal boundaries.

I'm not certain as to what the exact legal definition of occupancy is in terms of tenancy, but from my point of view, an occupancy would be something that included a leasing contract, payment of utilities, delivery of mail, tenant implements their own furnishings, etc. What if you took a week long vacation every month as the owner-occ, you know? It's quite murky.

The reasoning that the airbnb idea seems murky to me is that my girlfriend would be paying for utilities on her unit, she'd receive her mail at her unit, she'd furnish her own unit, legally it'd be her primary residency. If you airbnb'd your unit for a week to someone for 500$ for example there's no revolving lease contract or anything, that doesn't seem like occupancy to me, it seems like a smart move.

I'll definitely research a lot more into FHA's stance on occupancy, especially that 1 year occupancy piece of info that I see everybody mentioning around.

Post: Is it legal to airbnb a owner-occ unit in an owner-occ 4flat?

Alexander KostrubiecPosted
  • Real Estate Professional
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 1
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

Well, you could certainly have roommates, so...keep a room that's yours?

I should clarify the situation that I have in mind. I have a girlfriend of 7 years. While we're not married yet, though we plan on marriage. Our goal is to take advantage of our current standing as separate individuals not legally bound to one another and put FHA 3.5% minimum down-payments on an owner-occ 4flat with title held by myself, and a separate owner-occ 4flat with title held by her, so that we can have a start on investing in properties with less overall capital, rather than buying a single FHA 3.5% 4flat and then having to come up with enough capital for a 20%+ downpayment on an investment property. 3.5% of $300,000 is a down payment of $10,500 which is a lot less than 25% of $300,000 for example, which would be a $75,000 down payment.


We would be living together in one of the 4flats. One of the flats would be denoted as her primary residency for all intensive legal purposes, but she wouldn't truly be setting up camp in there. Thusly so, that would mean that in one of the 4flats, the intended owner-occ unit would be essentially useless to us for occupancy purposes. The tenancy/rent would obviously pay off the PITI, and that leaves us with an empty unit that cannot be designated as the legal residency of another persons.

We could use it as a storage area or something like that, but I was thinking if there was anything that can be done within legal limits with an owner-occ unit, such as airbnb, since in airbnb people will "rent" out their primary residencies.