@Kristine Norris I think some of the answer boils down to taking a good hard look at yourself and your expectations and your goals for the future.
How much time do you have to devote to management? Do you want to own 2 units or 50 units? Are you organized? Are you a people person? How do you handle conflict? Do you handle conflict well? Do you have a team in place? Are you willing to put a team in place?
Is earning an extra 10% worth spending a little more of your time on your real estate each month?
Bigger Pockets has great books on property management and rentals in general. If you get your forms organized and your team in place this significantly reduces the actual amount of time you have to spend on your properties each month.
I currently have 3 properties with 7 doors, soon to be 4 properties with 10 doors. (Maybe 5 for 12). Right now I spend about an hour each month on banking, for the past 4 months I’ve spent about 3 hours apiece on a flipper that’s almost done, and now that it’s summer and the grass is growing I’ll have about 4 hours a month of landscaping for 2 properties. The 3rd one I pay the snow removal and my neighbor mows the lawn, we share the driveway. So a total of 7 hours a month.
So without property management I make $1850 a month cash flow for 7 hours of time but my flip will go on the market in 2 weeks and profit $80,000 for a holding period of 1 year after all costs.
I don’t have a lot of maintenance calls because I do full rehabs on my buildings at initial turnover
But occasionally there’s something that I deal with. However my time is less expensive than a PM.