I like the FTHB tax credit idea personally. Being in an expensive market and having worked with first time home buyers a lot, it'll be nice to see them get help because they really need it when competing against more established buyers. It's basically impossible to get a first home here unless you have help, which is a bummer for those who aren't trust funders. $25k towards the down payment will even the playing field a bit.
I actually used the FTHB tax credit in 2009 ($8k tax credit at the time) which kick-started my real estate career. I paid $12k down and got $8k back so $4k out of pocket for my first property. Then I used the $8k to fix the property up. I did a value-add project to force appreciation, refinanced out enough cash to buy property #2 (without government assistance this time), turned property #1 into a rental, then repeated that process with property #2 and several more times over again and have since turned that initial $4k into a multi-million $ portfolio. So I'm a fan. It supports "The American Dream" in my opinion.
I hear the comments that the money has to come from somewhere. I see it as an $8k investment that the government made in me and they have done really well with it because I have paid that $8k back many times over in taxes that I've paid since then. Plus now that I'm established and have a portfolio, I pay a lot into the local economy by hiring contractors, buying materials, etc. I contribute a lot more now than I did as a renter.
Plus let's face it: it's a bit hypocritical to complain about tax incentives as real estate investors because we get a lot of tax advantages ourselves (write offs, depreciation, pass through deductions etc. these are some of the main reasons many people invest in real estate). It's not like we're talking about a "free market" here. A true free market doesn't exist as far as I know. People like to throw that term around, but a true free market would be anarchy and nobody wants that (or if they do they wouldn't like it for long). Real estate is propped up by govt. as it is, just mostly helping the already established more than beginners currently. It seems only fair to offer incentives to people just getting started as well, rather than just those of us who are already wealthy (like the guy running for president who is a billionaire but pays very little in taxes, and actually had the balls to write off $70k/year for doing his hair! If he can get $70k to glue his wig on in the morning, we can afford $25k for first time home buyers IMO, lol).
He also used a lot of other questionable tax-dodging strategies like writing off high-interest loans to his kids, fudging numbers on the value of his properties to pay less taxes, then fudging them the other way to get loans, etc. etc. etc.... let's not forget his company was found guilty of criminal tax fraud. We have no reason to trust anything he says, and every reason to know he's lying a lot and only running for president in hopes of staying out of prison.
No surprise that Trump plans to further cut taxes for himself and his extremely wealthy friends and family, just like the tax bills he passed as president. His 2017 tax laws seem to be written specifically for himself, lol. We've been trying and failing with trickle down economics for 40 years. It doesn't work, it's just an excuse for extremely wealthy people and politicians to pay less taxes. Let's try something else!