Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: AJ Cerbo

AJ Cerbo has started 7 posts and replied 12 times.

Looking for a lender in Arizona. I have a friend who's buying a new build home in Queen Creek - expected to close Mid November. Home price is 620k, planning on doing 5% down. They originally were going to use the developer's in-house lender, but were just informed the lender won't honor the income from their second job because they've only been working there 3 months. Looking for a lender who can use second job income (W2) to qualify. Thanks in advance

Home Price: 620k
Down Payment: 5% (31k)
Job 1 W-2 Income: 65k, held job since August 2023
Job 2 W-2 Income: 65k, held job since June 2024

Post: Landlord Insurance - Arizona

AJ CerboPosted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8

Hey everyone - looking for landlord insurance in Arizona. Currently have a condo and SFH that needs coverage. Please let me know if you have any recommendations!

Post: Multiple Tenants on Same Lease

AJ CerboPosted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8

Looking to lease out my property and for the first time dealing with a group of 3 friends who are interested in leasing together. Individually, they can't qualify with income, but as a group, they're well above my requirements. I've communicated with them if one member leaves, then the rent will fall on the shoulders of the other 2. I'd like to put them all on 1 lease for simplicity - my question is are there any potential pitfalls I'm missing? Any specific clauses that should be included in the case someone bails and the other 2 have to be responsible? A new friend replaces one of the members in a few months? etc.

Quote from @Richard F.:

Aloha,

We require they or a family member view the unit personally. We do not rent site unseen! If they want to move forward, we first advise them that if they are approved, we will need the deposit in certified check or money order only within two business days; and pro-rated rent prior to turning over keys by similar method (Once they move in, we have other payment options available). The rental agreement must start within 10 -12 days of approval, we will not hold longer without charging rent. We then provide an application to be completed and signed by anyone 18 or over that will be occupying. We require acceptable printed documentation of income (preferably showing year to date total earnings; hiring letter if new job plus last paystub), savings (they can redact the actual account number, but it must have enough identifying info to prove whose account it is), or whatever applies to their situation (passports, green cards, trust documents). We do not accept screen shots or ATM receipts!. We also will not accompany them to their bank safety deposit box so they can show us their gold (yes, I was recently asked to do so.)

We verify employment by looking up the business phone number (ignoring any provided by applicant) and contacting HR or management to verify their employment AND home address (if not printed on paycheck).

Next we run a local check for all occupants on the judiciary website. This will show traffic, civil, and criminal issues and local history. New arrivals we are able to access some jurisdictions court records, and also google etc. can provide a lot of interesting info. Most people fall into one of two groups- pretty clean records, with minor traffic issues; and NOT. The latter, more often than not, will fail the credit check which follows also.

Credit check is last, we pull direct from one of the Big Three. FICO score is not as important as what goes into making that score, so the score itself is not one of our criteria. The details are. This report also provides prior addresses and sometimes employment info, so now we look at the addresses and info across all of the collected documents to see if everything fits properly. If there are gaps, or time periods/addresses left out, we investigate further, and ask questions. Here is a chart that provides a little more insight to the scores:


We do process applications in the order received AND initially complete. We may request additional docs, or co-signer, depending on what has turned up, giving them limited time to produce them (usually one or two days max, depending on what is needed).

Once we have any additional requested docs or info, we make a decision and either send out (mail or email) a standardized denial letter, or call them and advise they have been approved. We then schedule a meeting for all adults to review and sign the documents at our office. I go through a consistent review of each document, answering any questions they may have, and having each page initialed by all, and signed/dated where appropriate. We then provide copies to each as needed of the full Rental Agreement package, and copy each person's ID for our records. When next we meet, it is to perform the walk through, move-in condition form. I would have already taken lots of pics of the ready-to-rent unit, and advise the new tenant they are welcome to take their own. Once completed, report signed, and copies provided to tenant, keys are turned over after reviewing any unusual or unique procedures or issues the tenant should be aware of. (Don't jerk the ceiling fan pull chains! How to properly operate the disposer. Location for rubbish. Days of rubbish pickup. Etc. Etc.))


 Thank you for this it is very thorough. What are your actual requirements? Income = 3x rent? 600 credit? Etc

Post: Eviction - Tenant Sending Money

AJ CerboPosted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8

How do you suppose I go about this? Block them on cashapp and zelle? And if in court they state to the judge I didn't give them an opportunity to receive payment? The eviction is for nonpayment of rent

Post: Eviction - Tenant Sending Money

AJ CerboPosted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8

Hi Everyone -

I have a tenant who is on their second eviction at my property. After filing with the court, the tenant sent me a partial payment via CashApp. During the court case, the judge informed me accepting any money forfeits the eviction.

My question is, if the tenant sends money again during the eviction process, and I immediately send it back, is that considered "not accepting"?


I'm unsure if there's any way around this unless I simply block their CashApp / Zelle. But then they may use that against me in court saying I wasn't allowing them the opportunity to pay. Any help is appreciated!

Post: Eviction - Tenant Forged Documents

AJ CerboPosted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8
Quote from @Al D.:

I understand the fraud/forgery part, which is material. But I am also curious: Are you evicting based only on the apparent lies in the application process, or has the tenant begun to default on any of the lease terms, like not paying rent?


 Not paying rent as well

Post: Eviction - Tenant Forged Documents

AJ CerboPosted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8
Quote from @Account Closed:
Quote from @AJ Cerbo:

Hey everyone -

Found out today my tenant faked their bank statements and employment. It was poor screening on my part (I used Zillow's rental manager, but didn't realize the income section wasn't verified). I'm in the process of filing an eviction, but I'm curious if there are larger legal implications here with them forging official documents like bank statements and lying about employment. I know after the eviction is approved they have another 5 days to vacate the property, but I'm concerned they'll trash the place after the judgement, and curious to see if I can get them out same day as the court hearing

That's a really interesting question.

I was assisting as a "professional witness" (I have professional experience) in a disputed real estate transaction, in federal court.

The plaintiff was clearly scamming the investor. All the proof was there.

In court, at trial, the plaintiff reversed his testimony to the totally opposite story that he had maintained for 2 and a half years. The judge realized the falsehood right away and the court transcriber had an audible, uncontrollable gasp at the new assertion. It was clearly perjury.

I expected some kind of punishment for the plaintiff for lying in federal court.

After deciding for the defendant, the judge closed out the case.


There was no comment from the judge on the obvious perjury and there was no referral to criminal investigation, it was just . . . dropped. Never to be discussed again. I was shocked. When I asked a different federal judge about the matter, he simply stated "everybody lies in court". I was just left stunned.

So, is it illegal to forge official documents. Yes. Will it wind up as a criminal investigation? Only if a prosecutor takes an interest in the case.

From this position, I see that when defaults on mortgages pick up, someone will decide they can get a promotion and good press for the department by chasing forgery, bank fraud, wire fraud, Consumer Protection Act, financial schemes.

But going after someone for lying to a landlord to get a rental: do this, take a fly fishing rod and go fly fishing for the weekend and forget about it. It ain't gonna happen.

Thanks Mike - and as for the tenant potential ally trashing the place after the judgement? Anything that can be done there to get them out sooner, ensure this doesn’t happen, get money to account for it happening, etc

Post: Eviction - Tenant Forged Documents

AJ CerboPosted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 8

Hey everyone -

Found out today my tenant faked their bank statements and employment. It was poor screening on my part (I used Zillow's rental manager, but didn't realize the income section wasn't verified). I'm in the process of filing an eviction, but I'm curious if there are larger legal implications here with them forging official documents like bank statements and lying about employment. I know after the eviction is approved they have another 5 days to vacate the property, but I'm concerned they'll trash the place after the judgement, and curious to see if I can get them out same day as the court hearing

Hey everyone -

Likely dealing with my first eviction; the tenant still has 3 days to pay before it gets filed with the court. Has anyone had any luck getting paid the money the tenant owes?

I'm not so concerned with removing the tenant, but she's going to owe a few thousand dollars from not paying her rent the last 2 months. Is there any way to actually recoup this money? Has anyone had any luck with garnishing wages, bank levy, debt collections, etc.