I moved out to Indy in late August 2016. I would agree with @Larry Fried that property inventory is very low, which has impacted turnkey providers. I have spoken with several providers and was impressed by FS House (@Ryan Mullin and Steve Lehman.) - I am in no way affiliated with FS House. I do know FS House is shifting its business model but I would have to defer to them to elaborate.
Regarding Indy real estate the city is pretty interesting as the areas and go from good to bad within a couple streets. Prior to moving forward, I would suggest you start reading everything you can about Indianapolis RE online, as well as understanding the positive and negatives of Turnkey. In the interim feel free to PM me with any questions.
I grew up in Central PA your profile mentions you will be moving to the Poconos so maybe look at the Pocono's and surrounding areas as investment opportunities. Stay safe in Afghanistan I was there 2012 - 2013. Most importantly, many thanks to you and your family for the sacrifice.