Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x

Posted almost 9 years ago

Single Family Rentals Vs. Multi-Family Rental Properties

Normal 1460318877 Single Multi Family Rental Properties

As an investor, one of the biggest questions you will have to ask yourself is if you’re going to invest in single family or multi-family rental properties.

Let’s analyze single family vs. multi-family rental properties, so you can make the very best choice when choosing your next Real Estate Investment.

Advantages of Investing In Multi-Family Rental Properties

One of the biggest advantages to investing in a multi-family rental property is that you will enjoy more property, while having less land, which is an advantage since the land under the multi-family rental is considered to be a non-performing asset.

Multi-family properties also offer good cash flow and the ability for an investor to consolidate all of their rental units on one parcel of land, maximizing the performing asset while minimizing their on-going costs.

Instead of owning multiple rental properties in one city or across United States, all of your rental units are in the same building and this means that the multi-family building also has one crawlspace, basement, gutters, yard and other ongoing expenses that need to be taken care instead of multiple expenses with more than one property.

Cons of Owning A Multi-Family Rental Property

Yes, multifamily rental properties can be a great investment, but as with any real estate investment they also come with their share of cons including the following:

  • Can Require More Property Management – Most multifamily rental properties in the real estate investment world are regarded as “transitional properties” because, renters typically choose an apartment, condo, townhome or duplex, as a short term rental property while they are saving for a home that they plan on buying or they are planning on moving into a long-term rental.
  • Intense Competition – Over the last two years multifamily rental properties have been in more demand than ever before because renters across multiple generations, including Baby Boomers, are renting instead of buying and with increased demand on multifamily rentals the competition with other owners has gotten more sophisticated. Some owners are offering their tenants more incentives like free WIFI, gym memberships and other incentives to renew their leases which have made it difficult for other owners to retain their renters.
  • More Costly – Multi-family rental properties are more costly to buy than single-family rentals because fewer multifamily rentals have been constructed across the United States since the real estate crash of 2007, driving up prices, making it more difficult for real estate investors to find multifamily rental properties.

Advantages of Owning Single Family Rental Properties

Single family rental properties are one of the best investments you can make. Especially over the last five years, thanks to low mortgage interest rates and excellent price across United States millions of investors have been able to get started with investing in real estate by purchasing an affordable single-family home. Even Baby Boomers and people who may have lost their homes to short sale or foreclosure in recent years want to rent single-family homes, because living in an actual house for most people is what they consider to be a home rather than living in an apartment or a multifamily rental property.

Some of the advantages of owning a single-family rental property include:

  • Rental Income – This is by far the biggest advantage of owning a single-family rental investment property since if you rent a typical single-family home anywhere across the United States for $1000 per month you will enjoy at least an additional $12,000 annually in your bank account. Although this income figure is optimistic, the reality is that even if you keep your rental property occupied for let’s say half of the year, that’s still an additional $5000 or more income from that rental property.
  • Increase In Property Value – Aside from the rental income that you enjoy from owning a single-family rental property the next advantage is that you will enjoy an increase in the value of your rental property. Property values vary depending upon area, but over the last two years we’ve seen property values increase across the United States and owning single-family homes has been an investment that even long time investors like Warren Buffett have sought out over other traditional investments.
  • Sweat Equity – There’s no denying that one the biggest advantages of owning a single-family home is that you also enjoy the advantage of sweat equity, because any time you put money into property it will ultimately increase the value of your single-family rental and enable you to charge more for rent as well.

Cons of Owning a Single Family Rental Property

Single family rental properties are an excellent asset. The only real con or disadvantages to this type of rental property is that all of your assets are concentrated in one small area. So if property values decline in that area, your property value may decline as well. Or if the area where your rental property is located sees an increase in crime, this could also affect the ability to rent your single-family rental for long periods of time.

Single Family Homes Are In High Demand

Yes, there are pros and cons to examine before making any Real Estate investment, but in the current real estate market, it’s easy to see why single-family rental properties are in high demand.



Comments (5)

  1. I am just looking at a Single family home property my REA sent me.Can be either a Flip or rental. Asking $27,000 and ARV, based on comps, is $49,000. Lots of multi-family properties in the area. Average rental is $550/month. House needs work on the inside, yard clean and big. Looking at the neighborhood(Trulia, Zillow, Realtytrac) shows a moderate to high crime rate and 6 offenders within 1 mile of this property.

    I am wholesaling just in the buy and flip fase. Any advise for a newbie?


  2. SFR - easier to get a mtg, 3.5% dn vs 30% 

             your buyers mkt are homeowners who wants a good buy vs investors who all want it wholesale

             tennant does the lawn, snow, garbage etc. , if a boiler goes down 1 family suffers vs 1 boiler = many families in MFR.


    1. Im not sure what market you are buying in, however in my area(NYC suburbs) unless you are a first time buyer going FHA, you are not getting a SFH for 3.5% down, also for non commercial properties, including MFH 4 units and under,its still a residential mortgage. I bought my first 2 family with FHA and 3.5% down. Also with commercial properties, MFH 5 units or better or store front etc.., to get favorable terms you would need 25% down. 30% down would be a home run for any lender. 


  3. Thanks for adding to the discussion Dan.


  4. I think you provided an incomplete picture here. The advantages you listed for a single family home are the same advantages that one might have with a MFH. Also you left a couple disadvantages off on SFH. Like if you lose your 1 renter, you lost all income and maintenance cost on a SFH, is comparable to a MFH. This of course depends on a number of factors, including which market you are investing in. Just my .02.