Michigan Landlords and Section 8: Navigating New Legislation

As legislative developments unfold in Michigan, landlords are keeping a close watch on how proposed laws could reshape the rental landscape, particularly concerning Section 8 housing.

Senate Bills 205-208, already approved by the Michigan State legislature, aim to make it illegal for landlords to discriminate based on income source, including Section 8 vouchers.

This potential change raises vital questions:

Can landlords still reject Section 8 tenants in Michigan?

For now, the answer remains yes, but this could soon change.

Let's delve into the legislation, its implications, and what it means for Michigan landlords.

Understanding the Proposed Legislation

The proposed bills signal a significant shift in landlord-tenant dynamics, particularly affecting financial screening processes—the primary tool landlords use to select tenants.

If enacted, these changes would mandate landlords with five or more rental units to accept Section 8 Housing Choice Vouchers.

This move aims to eliminate the option to refuse based on the program's voluntary nature, thus prohibiting income source discrimination.

Additionally, House Bill 4063 and Senate Bill 207 propose amending the Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act to include income source as a protected category, giving tenants a legal foundation to challenge discrimination.

Key Implications for Landlords

Should these bills become law, landlords could face legal repercussions for non-compliance, potentially leading to lawsuits where tenants might seek damages or injunctive relief.

The new rules would particularly impact landlords managing multiple properties, as they would be required to accept tenants with housing vouchers, thus altering the criteria used to evaluate potential renters.

The legislation underscores a move towards greater accountability and equitable access to housing, aligning with broader civil rights protections.

Exemptions and Legal Considerations

However, not all landlords would be subject to these new requirements.

There are notable exemptions designed to mitigate the law's impact.

Owner-occupied multifamily properties, where the landlord resides in one of the units, would be exempt.

Additionally, landlords owning five or fewer units, provided landlording isn't their primary income source, would also be exempt.

These exemptions aim to balance the legislation's impact, protecting small-scale and owner-occupied landlords from the broader obligations imposed on larger property managers.

Landlord Reactions and Concerns

Landlords across Michigan are expressing significant concerns about the proposed legislation. Senator Jeff Irwin (D-Ann Arbor), a supporter of the bills, stated that while landlords will retain the ability to accept or deny applicants based on various factors, they cannot refuse tenants solely due to their participation in public assistance programs.

This perspective highlights the broader goal of preventing income source discrimination, equating it with discrimination based on race or religion. However, landlords argue that income source directly influences a tenant's ability to pay rent, a critical factor in the tenant selection process.

The Property Management Association of Michigan has been vocal in opposing the bills, stressing that the Section 8 program's voluntary nature is crucial due to its operational inefficiencies.

The association is working with legislators to explore alternative solutions that enhance affordable housing access while addressing the needs of both landlords and tenants. They seek to develop workable solutions that do not mandate participation in the Section 8 program.

Staying Informed

As this legislation continues to develop, it's crucial for Michigan landlords and rental investors to stay informed about its progress and potential implications. While the Section 8 program remains voluntary for now, the potential for mandatory participation looms, bringing with it significant changes in how landlords select and manage tenants.

Stay informed about local laws, property development projects, and investor news across Metro Detroit and Michigan by subscribing to our newsletter.