Stainmaster vs Lifeproof vinyl plank flooring

[Joshua H.]

I'm looking to replace the flooring in an entire unit and debating between these two products. Although both Allure and Stainmaster have been around for a while, their waterproof lines are relatively new, so I haven't been able to find many longer term reviews. The Lifeproof is a Home Depot branded Allure product and the Stainmaster is partnered with Lowes. Lifeproof is roughly $2.80-3 sq ft and Stainmaster seems to be somewhat cheaper at $2.20-2.75 sq ft.

 The only complaint that I've consistently read is that an additional underlayment helps with any noise but I fear that may void the warranties. My biggest complaint between the two is the lack of light colored options without wild color variation.

Can anyone chime in with their experiences?

[Joaquin K.]

I wanted to add some details on my recent experience...

Our properties are in Southern California and are relatively high end. I typically use tile and carpet, but wanted to give vinyl plank a try.

I just used 1700 sq ft on a high end SFR turn. I shopped around quite a bit (considering quality and cost) since I generally like to select a vendor and then use that material moving forward (for all projects).

Home Depot stocks 4 colors of Lifeproof Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring, and they offer several other colors with 1 week lead time. I always use material that is stocked to avoid construction delays. I found the Home Depot pricing pretty good, and since I shop there all the time they are a preferred vendor. We also looked at Floor & Decor, Lumber Liquidators, and Lowes, as well as some online shops. Several companies offer non-interlocking panels that basically just lay on the floor (generally called "Loose Lay", and they are apparently very heavy and therefore don't need adhesive or interlocking). I would have given these a shot but could not find local supply at a reasonable price.

The list price of the Home Depot (in stock) Lifeproof "Essential Oak" was $2.79 /sq. ft. I have an HD Pro Account and was given an 18% discount on this relatively small order in the "bid room", so I felt pretty good about the price (effectively $2.28/sq ft). No adhesive or under-layer was required, and the material installs just like laminate. Each box has 8-10 planks, and I believe each of those planks is unique in look. Since the pattern repeats in the next box, its important to manage the installation so that two identical patterns (from separate boxes) don't lay side-by-side.

The floor looks really good, and I'm thrilled that its 100% waterproof.

I don't have any negative feedback to date, but will keep this thread updated if I identify and signs of accelerated wear.