Property Management Recommendations

[Jon Krombein]

Hey Everyone, I'm a new investor. I'm currently in the process of buying my first property through Roofstock.com in Indianapolis. The property I'm purchasing is currently rented and the property management company that's currently managing is AMG Property Management. I have the option to keep using them (which, absent any other information seems like that would make the most sense). Or, Roofstock also recommends Brick Lane or T&H Realty Services or I have the option to pick a different company if I can find them.

For those of you who are local (I am out of state), do any of you have any heartburn over AMG? Should I just stick with them? Alternately, any thoughts on Brick Lane or T&H? Or do any of you have a property manager that you just love and would recommend over the others?

Thanks in advance.