To paint or not original trim?!

[John Tarricone]

Happy Friday everyone!

I own a duplex in a historic district in Rochester NY. My house has beautiful detailed original dark wood trim (house built 1894).

I believe that renters prefer brighter spaces. I want to paint all the walls a light neutral gray. And then paint all the dark wood trim a bright white.

I’ve seen dozens of pictures- and been in houses with that scheme. And I just think it looks better. I think more renters would appreciate it and I could get more interest.

However- when I tell people this, they usually gasp and say “why would you ruin that beautiful wood”.

My thought is- the wood is still the same with the beautiful detail. It would just be a more modern and bright white.

What are your thoughts? Do you think painting trim white would appeal to more renters? Does this devalue my historic home?

Let me know. Thanks!

John T.