Need some input - what would you do?

[Craig Garrow]

To make a long story short, I manage some properties locally, and I had a couple of my maintenance guys over at one of the houses to do a quote on a roof repair. I got a call a couple of hours later from the tenant's boyfriend (who also lives there) saying that the girlfriend's wallet was light $100.00. Supposedly they checked everywhere, and the girlfriend claims that she was with the guys "most of the time they were there" but could think of a couple of times they were in the same room as her wallet and without her. Now, these guys have done a bunch of work for me and other customers, and they're in and out of people's houses all the time and I've never once had an issue. I'm just looking to see what you guys would've done and compare it to how I handled the situation. Any input is greatly appreciated!