Landlords....What would you require in this scenario?

[John D.]

Potential tenants for the 2nd floor of a duplex are 20 and 19 with no credit/rental history.  I did confirm employment and background and both came back fine.  Neither prospect has worked for their employer more than a year and both are FT students.  I checked social media sites and those look clean as well (no partying, no meth labs, etc.)  One works FT and grosses $3500/m and the other only works PT and grosses $500/m.  Rent is $875 and property is in NJ.

Any and all opinions and suggestions are appreciated!!

Thanks all!!