General Landlording & Rental Properties
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
![](http://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/assets/forums/sponsors/hospitable-deef083b895516ce26951b0ca48cf8f170861d742d4a4cb6cf5d19396b5eaac6.png)
Landlording & Rental Properties
![](http://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/assets/forums/sponsors/hemlane-a9392011949df124ea8ee63be2fb270c9423d6cd446ec67af23c96616e618606.png)
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback
![Mary Jay's profile image](https://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/no_overlay/uploads/social_user/user_avatar/941288/1694565296-avatar-maryjay.jpg?twic=v1/output=image/cover=128x128&v=2)
What reason is ok to use to refuse tenant in renting? (Is misdemeanor a good reason?)
Hi guys,
What reason is ok to use to refuse tenant in renting? (Is misdemeanor a good reason?)
State Florida...
![Tim Baldwin's profile image](https://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/no_overlay/uploads/social_user/user_avatar/2705023/1716307682-avatar-timbaldwin.jpg?twic=v1/output=image/crop=533x533@246x0/cover=128x128&v=2)
Depends. The reason must be base on an objective, non-discriminatory selection criteria. Persons with a criminal record are not a protected class. However, under the "Disparate Impact" legal theory, fair housing issues arise when denying persons with a criminal record involving non-serious offenses and offenses that are remote in time.
A misdemeanor may be sufficient to deny application if the conviction was recent and didn't involve a more serious crime, such as battery or intentional property damage. But if the conviction is remote in time (e.g. over 3 years ago) and didn't involve intentional property damage or bodily harm, perhaps the conviction is not sufficient cause.
You can read up on "Disparate Impact" Theory on a variety of landlord resource websites, including government agencies.
Other reasons for denial involve other risk factors, such as,
1. rental history and prior landlord verification
2. credit score
3. employment history and verification
4. income v. rent ratio
etc.
![Nathan Gesner's profile image](https://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/no_overlay/uploads/social_user/user_avatar/51525/1621411521-avatar-soldat.jpg?twic=v1/output=image/cover=128x128&v=2)
Quote from @Mary Jay:
I disagree with blanket rejections.
The point of screening an applicant is to determine the level of risk to your property, your income, and others. A felony conviction and ten years in prison sounds pretty bad, but were they guilty of embezzling money from their employer, or were they guilty of raping the next-door neighbor? Those present two very different levels of risk.
You should also consider how long ago the offense occurred and what the individual has done since then. If they spent ten years in prison for drug dealing, but have been out for ten years, have been sober, stayed employed, and paid their bills, there's really no risk associated with their criminal past.
![](https://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/no_overlay/uploads/ads/forum_ad/hero_image/919/PM_Finder_-_Forum_Display_1.png?twic=v1/output=image/contain=520x226)
![Charles Perkins's profile image](https://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/no_overlay/uploads/social_user/user_avatar/2955675/1712280043-avatar-charlesp293.jpg?twic=v1/output=image/crop=3024x3024@0x503/cover=128x128&v=2)
Quote from @Nathan Gesner:
Quote from @Mary Jay:
I disagree with blanket rejections.
The point of screening an applicant is to determine the level of risk to your property, your income, and others. A felony conviction and ten years in prison sounds pretty bad, but were they guilty of embezzling money from their employer, or were they guilty of raping the next-door neighbor? Those present two very different levels of risk.
You should also consider how long ago the offense occurred and what the individual has done since then. If they spent ten years in prison for drug dealing, but have been out for ten years, have been sober, stayed employed, and paid their bills, there's really no risk associated with their criminal past.
As we review screening criteria results we also like to create an overall risk assessment. This makes more sense to us than relying strictly on rigid yes or no criteria where any negative disqualifies a candidate entirely.
Some criteria is weighted more heavily and can overcome negatives. It can be quite subjective but based on our past experiences it has worked for us.
![Russell Brazil's profile image](https://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/no_overlay/uploads/social_user/user_avatar/120988/1621417798-avatar-russelltee.jpg?twic=v1/output=image/crop=303x303@52x0/cover=128x128&v=2)
I think something like 40% of Americans have misdemeanors.
Some things that are misdemeanors
Speeding
Jaywalking
Open Container in public
Driving without a license
Excessive noise
Littering
Driving with expired tags
Using very low level misdemeanors to prove a point that these are all ridiculous reasons to deny a tenant.
![Mary Jay's profile image](https://bpimg.biggerpockets.com/no_overlay/uploads/social_user/user_avatar/941288/1694565296-avatar-maryjay.jpg?twic=v1/output=image/cover=128x128&v=2)
thank you guys soooo much!!!