Tenant broke hanging light pendant before move out

[Albert Johnson]

One of my tenants is moving out. The tenant stated they broke one of the hanging glass light pendants. It's a total of three. 

The tenant is stating they can't find the exact same one and can replace all 3 for $40.

what would you do in this situation?

I was planning to find something close and send it to them. (It's more expensive) Or just ask them to get something close to they style and send me a picture before replacing.