Selling timber on land before development

Selling timber on land before development

Real Estate Agent · Richmond, VA · Member since 2018 · 104 posts · 36 votes

I have 38 acres of wooded land under contract and I'm thinking about having it logged. I have read a little about the process but would like to hear from people that have first-hand experience. Would you recommend hiring a private forester to survey the trees? How were they paid? Did you have to pay upfront or after the sale? How much of the selling process did they handle? 

My plan for the land is to eventually sell it to a developer. Would you recommend having it cleared before listing it? Does it make it more or less attractive to the developer? 

0Reply
101 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
5y
Originally posted by @Bill B.:

You might be on the wrong coast for detailed help. But @Jay Hinrichs has years of experience including purchasing timber. 

This can be regional for sure, one thing folks can do to really understand what they have is hire a 3rd party independent forester and have them do a cruise on the property. This will identify species  any logging hurdles  and prices for delivered logs, Mills to take them to etc. well worth the dollars. And its like any appraisal you pay for it up front or when its completed. Many foresters will also have the ability to hire out all the logging actives as well and do that for you.

You can hire a Gypo logger to log it. what is being described above as pay as they cut it  is commonly known as a % contract.. logger takes a certain % land owner gets the balance.. the Mills are used to split payments.  Or there are probably firms like us were we bought the timber deed and paid cash before we started Land owner takes zero risk on the income.

Buying timber is no different for the companies as described above as a wholesaler in SFRs operates today,  you identify timber that is worth money and you solicit them. And its far easier to do this today with Google earth than it was in my day. However that's exactly how we ran our business direct mail and telemarked.. 

Also out this way there is replant that must be done. So need to negotiate the replant if any.  I have no doubt delivered log prices are up as lumber as we know has sky rocketed but I have not seen that be a direct correlation to the delivered log price its the mill and the lumber brokers that are killing it.. 

On the Developer side of things leaving a stump farm is not optimum for a developer many times developer wants the Timber so they can off set the pulling of the stumps.. those have to be removed to develop.

And then you have Land use issues and tree protection all this has to play into these developments. 

See this reply in the discussion

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Lynden, Ontario · Member since 2017 · 90 posts · 19 votes
    5y

    I think there was a BP podcast on this topic many yrs ago...maybe

  • Developer · DC & NC · Member since 2019 · 113 posts · 95 votes
    5y

    I have a similarly sized parcel that was recently logged. The company sent an unsolicited letter offering, and sent out an appraiser. The numbers sounded fine, and they ended up paying considerably more than that, on a pay-as-cut basis. Pine is in high demand right now!

    As a developer, something that's already cleared is a bit of a bonus. Tree preservation ordinances are usually based on what's forested, and well, you can't preserve what isn't there.

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    5y

    You might be on the wrong coast for detailed help. But @Jay Hinrichs has years of experience including purchasing timber. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Bill B.:

    You might be on the wrong coast for detailed help. But @Jay Hinrichs has years of experience including purchasing timber. 

    This can be regional for sure, one thing folks can do to really understand what they have is hire a 3rd party independent forester and have them do a cruise on the property. This will identify species  any logging hurdles  and prices for delivered logs, Mills to take them to etc. well worth the dollars. And its like any appraisal you pay for it up front or when its completed. Many foresters will also have the ability to hire out all the logging actives as well and do that for you.

    You can hire a Gypo logger to log it. what is being described above as pay as they cut it  is commonly known as a % contract.. logger takes a certain % land owner gets the balance.. the Mills are used to split payments.  Or there are probably firms like us were we bought the timber deed and paid cash before we started Land owner takes zero risk on the income.

    Buying timber is no different for the companies as described above as a wholesaler in SFRs operates today,  you identify timber that is worth money and you solicit them. And its far easier to do this today with Google earth than it was in my day. However that's exactly how we ran our business direct mail and telemarked.. 

    Also out this way there is replant that must be done. So need to negotiate the replant if any.  I have no doubt delivered log prices are up as lumber as we know has sky rocketed but I have not seen that be a direct correlation to the delivered log price its the mill and the lumber brokers that are killing it.. 

    On the Developer side of things leaving a stump farm is not optimum for a developer many times developer wants the Timber so they can off set the pulling of the stumps.. those have to be removed to develop.

    And then you have Land use issues and tree protection all this has to play into these developments. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Near Memphis, Tenn. · Member since 2019 · 88 posts · 34 votes
    5y

    Matthew

    Good advice you received above.  My developer friends do not care for logged timber land as they say the stumps will cost more to remove than the money you made from the logging.  Now in our area that is usally because it is pine and the price is down.

    If the bid from a logger or broker is for hardwood and more valuable, then math wins in the decision.

    it will take years for hardwood stumps to rot on their own and less time for pine stumps.  If you are selling to a developer then the time frame from logging to potential sale should factor in the stumps.  Once stumps are there and it is going to be a few years before sale to adeveloper, then hard to keep cut with a bushhog with all those stumps and tree tops left behind.  PS loggers alwas promise not to leave limbs and tops behind but...

    We are about to do 10 acre lots on 400 acres.

    A wise friend advised us to lidar scan the area to determine best location for roads and lots.  Then select cut by pushing tree over first then cut log (trackhoe can do) only in areas for roads, etc.  

    Then buyer who may want a wooded lot has trees, if buyer not want, then we can cut for them then.

    We will add the value of the lumber on the lot sale price as wooded lots here are diferent and thus more valuable for the folks who want that product.

    hope this helps,

    De

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @De Rasche:

    Matthew

    Good advice you received above.  My developer friends do not care for logged timber land as they say the stumps will cost more to remove than the money you made from the logging.  Now in our area that is usally because it is pine and the price is down.

    If the bid from a logger or broker is for hardwood and more valuable, then math wins in the decision.

    it will take years for hardwood stumps to rot on their own and less time for pine stumps.  If you are selling to a developer then the time frame from logging to potential sale should factor in the stumps.  Once stumps are there and it is going to be a few years before sale to adeveloper, then hard to keep cut with a bushhog with all those stumps and tree tops left behind.  PS loggers alwas promise not to leave limbs and tops behind but...

    We are about to do 10 acre lots on 400 acres.

    A wise friend advised us to lidar scan the area to determine best location for roads and lots.  Then select cut by pushing tree over first then cut log (trackhoe can do) only in areas for roads, etc.  

    Then buyer who may want a wooded lot has trees, if buyer not want, then we can cut for them then.

    We will add the value of the lumber on the lot sale price as wooded lots here are diferent and thus more valuable for the folks who want that product.

    hope this helps,

    De

    I was going to mention pushing over the tree's to pop out the root ball  that is far cheaper way to go.. out on the West coast FIr is far more valuable than hardwood.. hardwood is darn near a weed..  Very few mills left anymore that manufacture hardwood.  So a lot of it just goes for hog fuel.. or paper products.   Good luck on your project.. And most certainly the standing trees have more ascetic value to the resale of the property then taking all the Timber unless your creating vineyards or some other ag use. 

  • New to Real Estate · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2021 · 13 posts · 13 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    I have 38 acres of wooded land under contract and I'm thinking about having it logged. I have read a little about the process but would like to hear from people that have first-hand experience. Would you recommend hiring a private forester to survey the trees? How were they paid? Did you have to pay upfront or after the sale? How much of the selling process did they handle? 

    My plan for the land is to eventually sell it to a developer. Would you recommend having it cleared before listing it? Does it make it more or less attractive to the developer? 

    Matthew - 

    Congratulations! Purchasing and closing on a timberland property is very rewarding. I especially like how you are considering having the trees harvested and potentially selling the land to a developer. If you do go that route consider having the tree stumps removed. That will attract even more buyers.

    I love to nerd out about these things and that's why I went to school to pursue a career in Procurement Forestry. 

    Selling timber is a serious matter requiring careful preparation and the first place I recommend you start is hiring a Registered Consulting Forester to help with the planning, execution and closeout of the sale of your timber. Relying on the expertise of a consultant reduces the likelihood that sellers or buyers will be caught off guard - and that helps landowners, like you, get the highest return for their timber.

    You can find a Registered Consulting Forester through the Association of Consulting Foresters.

    I'll give you a high level overview of what a consultant will help you with. 

    A consultant will:

    1. Help the landowner develop a forest management plan.
    2. Plan the pre-harvest.
    3. Determine a selling method.
    4. Establish a written contract between the landowner and the buyer and/or logger.
    5. Help the landowner execute the sale and harvest.
    6. Will monitor the harvest operations of the buyer and/or logger.
    7. Closeout the harvest with the buyer and/or logger.

      I can give more specifics about actions 1 through 7 if you'd like. I specialize in steps 3 through 7 from the buyer perspective. I oversee the management of the purchase and harvest of timberland in Georgia for several sawmills that produce dimensional lumber. I'm an open book!

      Depending on your sale method the consultant will be paid a commission that is a percentage of the timber sale. I'm not familiar of any upfront fees, but can ask my those in my forestry network on how they handle new clients.

      Since this post is 5 months old at this point, how'd you move forward with your wooded lot. I'd also like to know what was the process/setps associated with purchasing timberland from your perspective? 
       

    1. Investor · Canton, GA · Member since 2014 · 728 posts · 501 votes
      5y

      @Matthew Jones

      I’m a GA Registered Forester.

      What do you want to know?

    Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.