Skip to content
Buying & Selling Real Estate

User Stats

319
Posts
103
Votes
DJ Cummins
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Bethalto, IL
103
Votes |
319
Posts

Sub30k rental purchase... should i stay or should i go now?

DJ Cummins
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Bethalto, IL
Posted Sep 4 2015, 06:30

Good morning everyone,

Looking for some opinions here.  My wife and I currently own a 4 unit Multi-Family(20% down pmt), and are cash flowing about $750.00 per month, give or take a tad.  We are excited and are ready to start preparing ourselves for purchase number two.  

I have read  dozens of posts (for/against) buying lower valued "pigs."  There are dozens of properties that we could buy in our area from 30-50k.  We live in the midwest, 20 minutes from St. Louis, Missouri, on the Illinois side of the river.  These homes are in safe area(i have lived here all 33 years of my life), mainly class B and C.  If I am cautious about the big ticket capex items(roof, heat/air), what is the harm in purchasing these types of property?  

Just as an fyi-i googled(not the most accurate-just quick) the average home price in my area, compared to Lima, Ohio.  Lima has an average listing price of $122,790.00.  The median home price in my area is $71,500.00.  Homes are just cheaper than a lot of other areas here where we live at(so are the salaries... #sadface).  So we can get fairly nice properties at 30-50k here because that is just the way the market is.  We could get between 600-750 in rent out of these properties.  Obviously if i were to buy one, i would try and make a few updates...laminate flooring, new paint, new plumbing fixtures/toilets(all work i can do myself at a pretty cheap price).  @Ben Leybovich...i would love to hear your opinion.  i respect all that you have accomplished, and would like to hear your thoughts on this.  I know you are against the cheap houses...but what if all houses are relatively cheap?  

I would like to hear from other people as well...not just Ben.  I just wanted to "askbenwhy."  Thanks to all, and sorry for the long post.  Have a great Labor Day Weekend!

DJ

User Stats

1,284
Posts
1,231
Votes
Joe Bertolino
  • Investor
  • El Dorado Hills, CA
1,231
Votes |
1,284
Posts
Joe Bertolino
  • Investor
  • El Dorado Hills, CA
Replied Sep 4 2015, 06:39
My 02 cents: Buying a $30k pig is fine if you live 20 mins away. You understand the area and can deal with most issues quickly, efficiently and in person. If you can get a 2/1 or 3/2 in decent shape in a decent/safe area that rents for 1.5-2% then go for it. Living in CA or NY and investing in a $50k pig (aka a $30k pig with some turnkey lipstick) and relying on somebody else to watch after it in a structure where their profit motives (in house repairs and lease ups) do not align with yours... is a terrible idea.

User Stats

4,456
Posts
4,294
Votes
Ben Leybovich
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Phoenix/Lima, Arizona/OH
4,294
Votes |
4,456
Posts
Ben Leybovich
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Phoenix/Lima, Arizona/OH
Replied Sep 4 2015, 06:40
Originally posted by @DJ Cummins:

Good morning everyone,

Looking for some opinions here.  My wife and I currently own a 4 unit Multi-Family(20% down pmt), and are cash flowing about $750.00 per month, give or take a tad.  We are excited and are ready to start preparing ourselves for purchase number two.  

I have read  dozens of posts (for/against) buying lower valued "pigs."  There are dozens of properties that we could buy in our area from 30-50k.  We live in the midwest, 20 minutes from St. Louis, Missouri, on the Illinois side of the river.  These homes are in safe area(i have lived here all 33 years of my life), mainly class B and C.  If I am cautious about the big ticket capex items(roof, heat/air), what is the harm in purchasing these types of property?  

Just as an fyi-i googled(not the most accurate-just quick) the average home price in my area, compared to Lima, Ohio.  Lima has an average listing price of $122,790.00.  The median home price in my area is $71,500.00.  Homes are just cheaper than a lot of other areas here where we live at(so are the salaries... #sadface).  So we can get fairly nice properties at 30-50k here because that is just the way the market is.  We could get between 600-750 in rent out of these properties.  Obviously if i were to buy one, i would try and make a few updates...laminate flooring, new paint, new plumbing fixtures/toilets(all work i can do myself at a pretty cheap price).  @Ben Leybovich...i would love to hear your opinion.  i respect all that you have accomplished, and would like to hear your thoughts on this.  I know you are against the cheap houses...but what if all houses are relatively cheap?  

I would like to hear from other people as well...not just Ben.  I just wanted to "askbenwhy."  Thanks to all, and sorry for the long post.  Have a great Labor Day Weekend!

DJ

 You've just given me the topic for the next blog post :)

In your case - perhaps. There are a lot of caveats, but perhaps yes.

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

319
Posts
103
Votes
DJ Cummins
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Bethalto, IL
103
Votes |
319
Posts
DJ Cummins
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Bethalto, IL
Replied Sep 4 2015, 06:54

@Joe Bertolino - i will be looking forward to your blog post...always enjoy them.  I am just excited to see that you said "perhaps."  Maybe i am not as crazy after all.  ha-ha.  

User Stats

4,456
Posts
4,294
Votes
Ben Leybovich
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Phoenix/Lima, Arizona/OH
4,294
Votes |
4,456
Posts
Ben Leybovich
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Phoenix/Lima, Arizona/OH
Replied Sep 4 2015, 06:59
Originally posted by @DJ Cummins:

@Joe Bertolino - i will be looking forward to your blog post...always enjoy them.  I am just excited to see that you said "perhaps."  Maybe i am not as crazy after all.  ha-ha.  

 Oh - you are nuts! Flat out! But, still may be :)

Started writing as we speak. Will be out on Tue I imagine...

User Stats

112
Posts
57
Votes
Gunnar Teltow
  • Investor
  • Austin, TX
57
Votes |
112
Posts
Gunnar Teltow
  • Investor
  • Austin, TX
Replied Sep 4 2015, 10:43

DJ, this may be too specific for almost everyone but right now there's a glut of investor-owned 2/1s in North County in St. Louis County. A lot of the housing stock there (even in better areas like Florissant) has only one bathroom so that's OK but definitely stay away from the 2/1s as they're hard to rent right now. 

Overall rental demand in North County is quite good if you have decent product. We have a little over 200 SFRs there now and no trouble keeping them rented (YMMV).

User Stats

1,284
Posts
490
Votes
Frankie Woods
  • Investor
  • Arlington, VA
490
Votes |
1,284
Posts
Frankie Woods
  • Investor
  • Arlington, VA
Replied Sep 7 2015, 00:56

I believe 30k properties can work if bought right.  It is all dependent on the market.  However, @Ben Leybovich, and many other investors, have talked in breadth as to why it may not be a good idea to buy these types of properties.  I have 3 multiplexes in STL that are pigs, and they are doing ok, but I'm already seeing a lot of the problems others have described.  So, though I will hold on to the properties I own for now, I will not be purchasing anymore.  Wishing you the best of luck!

User Stats

320
Posts
100
Votes
Kyle Penland
  • Investor
  • Dyersburg, TN
100
Votes |
320
Posts
Kyle Penland
  • Investor
  • Dyersburg, TN
Replied Sep 7 2015, 05:15
It's all about how you manage the property and what money you sink into it. When you are in this price range you have to get creative. Please feel free to reach out to me to discuss how I make my properties work.