"Formality" of 1031 Exchange Process

"Formality" of 1031 Exchange Process

Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 0 votes

Hello BP family, I had question about 1031 and reverse 1031 exchanges. I know this is  an oversimplification, but coming from a legal background Im trying to understand whats going on in a 1031. My impression of the process is that its kind of "informal" in the sense that it really only involves the exchanger and QI with the idea being  that the transaction is being properly documented (such as identifying a prop w/in 45 days) and structured (i.e. making sure the exchanger doesn't receive or control both properties or proceeds) in accordance with IRS rules. Once the transaction is complete you would file your yearly taxes and indicate the sale but defer payment of cap gains taxes on the basis of the 1031. 

With that said, is it correct to say the IRS (or govt for that matter) doesn't get involved unless you're basically being audited/investigated? The documents used specifically for the 1031 (such as the Exchange agreement or writing identifying props to acquire) are not sent or filed with the IRS/govt; they are more important after the fact to demonstrate and prove to Uncle Same why capital gains were not owed on that transaction, should an audit occur? Is it correct to say that there is basically no affirmative "approval" received when doing a 1031; there is really only a disapproval of one in the form of a failed audit.  

0Reply
35 views

Most Popular Reply

CES® , Qualified Intermediary for 1031 Exchanges · McKinney, TX · Member since 2018 · 42 posts · 144 votes
3y

Hello @Mike Nas

What you wrote is essentially correct. While there is no formal "approval" process involving the IRS/govt during an exchange, all of the steps, people (QI), and documents involved in executing an exchange are required formalities. They MUST be apart of the formal exchange process or it doesn't exist and will fail. As @Jeff Nash explained, when filing their taxes and reporting the exchange on Form 8824 the CPA/tax preparer will need a copy of the exchange documents, closing statements (which also have 1031 language on them), etc. to report it properly. If not reported properly the likelihood of an audit increases. Also, a qualified intermediary helps the client execute an exchange according to the rules/laws to help mitigate any potential for a future IRS disapproval. They will make determinations/give advice along the way that are essentially approvals/disapprovals so that the client doesn't do something that they shouldn't which could cause the exchange to fail and be taxable. 

See this reply in the discussion

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Accountant · McKinney, TX · Member since 2023 · 394 posts · 580 votes
    3y

    Hi Mike, there is no IRS approval letter that you receive (say for like an S-Corp election) but you take the tax position that your transaction meets the merits of a 1031 exchange when Form 8824 is filed. Obviously the exchange documents (agreement, ID letter, etc) and tax return have document retention requirements and those would be needed to facilitate any IRS or state tax inquiries.  

  • CES® , Qualified Intermediary for 1031 Exchanges · McKinney, TX · Member since 2018 · 42 posts · 144 votes
    3y

    Hello @Mike Nas

    What you wrote is essentially correct. While there is no formal "approval" process involving the IRS/govt during an exchange, all of the steps, people (QI), and documents involved in executing an exchange are required formalities. They MUST be apart of the formal exchange process or it doesn't exist and will fail. As @Jeff Nash explained, when filing their taxes and reporting the exchange on Form 8824 the CPA/tax preparer will need a copy of the exchange documents, closing statements (which also have 1031 language on them), etc. to report it properly. If not reported properly the likelihood of an audit increases. Also, a qualified intermediary helps the client execute an exchange according to the rules/laws to help mitigate any potential for a future IRS disapproval. They will make determinations/give advice along the way that are essentially approvals/disapprovals so that the client doesn't do something that they shouldn't which could cause the exchange to fail and be taxable. 

  • Dave FosterBusiness Member
    Qualified Intermediary for 1031 Exchanges · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2013 · 9k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    3y

    @Mike Nas, Informal is a tough characterization.  The joke has always been that every 1031 is "GTO" (good till audited).  The reality is that a 1031 exchange is an exacting and rigid order of process requiring specific documentation and adhering to very specific timelines.  It is true that there is no "approval process" is a double-edged sword.  On one hand, anyone can do one.  On the other hand, it can be tempting to skirt the complete process.  Or short some of the required actions.  

    And this is why the IRS requires that an unrelated 3rd party called the qualified intermediary document the exchange and hold the proceeds in between sale and purchase.  

    So many of the IRS regs involve you begging forgiveness rather than asking permission!  This is why following the process exactly is the key to you sleeping at night.  The advice should be to "Don't ever do a 1031 exchange just because it won't be audited.  But also don't ever not do a 1031 just because it might be questioned."  Instead, do it exactly right.  Have your situation documented well.  And then don't worry further.  

    The 1031 Investor5140 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.