Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x

Business Page


business profile image

Renters Warehouse Milwaukee

Property Manager
3.8 stars
253 Reviews

Markets served


Kenosha, WI
West Allis, WI
West Bend, WI
Waukesha, WI
Milwaukee, WI
Brown Deer, WI
Racine, WI
New Berlin, WI

Licenses, Designations or Certificates


Real Estate Broker 
Dwelling Contractor 

About us


At Renters Warehouse Milwaukee, we are dedicated to providing top-tier residential property management services that ensure both property owners and tenants experience seamless, stress-free living. With years of expertise in the real estate industry, we specialize in managing single-family homes, condominiums, and multi-unit residences, delivering exceptional service with a personal touch.

Our mission is to maximize property value and rental income while maintaining high tenant satisfaction. We achieve this through proactive maintenance, responsive communication, and innovative technology solutions. Whether you’re an investor looking for reliable management or a tenant seeking a well-maintained home, we are committed to excellence at every step.

Specialties


HUD/Section 8

Single Home/Townhome/Condo
Multi-family: 2-4 units
Multi-family: 5-19 units
Multi-family: 20-49 units

Long-term rental: 12+ mos.

Single Home/Townhome/Condo
Multi-family: 2-4 units
Multi-family: 5-19 units
Multi-family: 20-49 units

Other Property Management Services

HOA/Associations
Mid-term rental: 1-12 mos.
Student Housing

Reviews (253)


3.8 stars
253 Reviews
3.8 stars
253 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews

reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Vidal
As an external contractor, I’ve had an excellent experience with Renters Warehouse. Their team is very professional and efficient, and I especially want to highlight Celeste. From the very first interaction, she was extremely respectful, kind, and always attentive to detail. Her professionalism made the process smooth and stress-free. It’s clear that she genuinely cares about providing the best service possible. I would definitely recommend Renters Warehouse to anyone looking for high-quality maintenance services. Thank you for everything, Celeste and the team!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Leelee
As a someone who works in the service industry I have a close working relationship with Renters Warehouse to complete repairs at their locations and I have never had any issues with the company. I strongly believe that one of the majors reasons for this is due to Celeste who is consistently in contact with me, providing information in a timely matter. We're also are given a proper owner approval before hand so we can complete the job as we are out there so we don't have any issues later.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
10 months ago
Reviewed by Ryan
I have gone through Renters' Warehouse Milwaukee for 7 years while I had my investment property. The staff were very professional, friendly, proficient, and super easy to work with. They were always quick to respond to correspondence or address issues before they became problematic. I never had to worry about property management issues, and overall the ownership of my rental property was a stress-free experience due to how well Renters' Warehouse performed. When it came time to sell, Renters' Warehouse offered the best rates when it came to relators, and selling via the property management company was a smooth and easy process. My relator worked hard for me to get me the best price, and provided expert advice at each decision point along the way. Closing was quick, easy, and seamless. I am extremely satisfied with my experience, and I would definitely leverage their services again if I were to get another rental property.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a year ago
Reviewed by Arthur Johnson
Our company has been working with Renters Warehouse for the past few years and we can’t help but notice the dedication they have towards their clients/tenants. Celest is always professional and responds quickly anytime we have concerns regarding the issue at hand at any given property. She communicates effectively with not just our company but also their clients. Renters Warehouse values their clients and their needs, they strive to ensure their clients get the help they need in a quick and efficient manner.
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
a year ago
Reviewed by Kaitlin Rhodes
Doesn’t answer calls or emails. Will let your unit sit for over 4 months and still won’t post your unit for rent. My renter also had difficulty with them not fixing issues and would only contact her when the rent is due and still not fix the issues for her. Money hungry PMs that don’t care about losing you thousands of dollars.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Moises Herrera Llanes
Renters Warehouse Milwaukee is managing the new house we just moved into. They have been super responsive, attentive, and wonderful to work with. Cristina is fantastic and we look forward to continues excellent service!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Marcela Garilus
Working with Renters Warehouse has been an excellent experience. We have interacted with many members of their team, they are all very responsive to the many questions we have and they are all very professional and knowledgeable. I highly recommend working with them.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
5 years ago
Reviewed by Zach
Hiring Renters Warehouse was one of the best decisions I have ever made. In the past, I always had problems with my tenants. They never paid rent, they always complained about small maintenance requests, and they always left my property looking like garbage. I hired Renters Warehouse last summer, and since then everything has been a breeze. Owen from the team found me great tenants who pay rent, and they never complain about small maintenance requests like changing lightbulbs or clogged toilets. Josh from the maintenance department is always very good with communication and gets things done fast. I'm happy, and my tenants are happy. Thanks guys, looking forward to another great year of owning a rental property!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Vidal
As an external contractor, I’ve had an excellent experience with Renters Warehouse. Their team is very professional and efficient, and I especially want to highlight Celeste. From the very first interaction, she was extremely respectful, kind, and always attentive to detail. Her professionalism made the process smooth and stress-free. It’s clear that she genuinely cares about providing the best service possible. I would definitely recommend Renters Warehouse to anyone looking for high-quality maintenance services. Thank you for everything, Celeste and the team!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Leelee
As a someone who works in the service industry I have a close working relationship with Renters Warehouse to complete repairs at their locations and I have never had any issues with the company. I strongly believe that one of the majors reasons for this is due to Celeste who is consistently in contact with me, providing information in a timely matter. We're also are given a proper owner approval before hand so we can complete the job as we are out there so we don't have any issues later.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
10 months ago
Reviewed by Ryan
I have gone through Renters' Warehouse Milwaukee for 7 years while I had my investment property. The staff were very professional, friendly, proficient, and super easy to work with. They were always quick to respond to correspondence or address issues before they became problematic. I never had to worry about property management issues, and overall the ownership of my rental property was a stress-free experience due to how well Renters' Warehouse performed. When it came time to sell, Renters' Warehouse offered the best rates when it came to relators, and selling via the property management company was a smooth and easy process. My relator worked hard for me to get me the best price, and provided expert advice at each decision point along the way. Closing was quick, easy, and seamless. I am extremely satisfied with my experience, and I would definitely leverage their services again if I were to get another rental property.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
a year ago
Reviewed by Arthur Johnson
Our company has been working with Renters Warehouse for the past few years and we can’t help but notice the dedication they have towards their clients/tenants. Celest is always professional and responds quickly anytime we have concerns regarding the issue at hand at any given property. She communicates effectively with not just our company but also their clients. Renters Warehouse values their clients and their needs, they strive to ensure their clients get the help they need in a quick and efficient manner.
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
a year ago
Reviewed by Kaitlin Rhodes
Doesn’t answer calls or emails. Will let your unit sit for over 4 months and still won’t post your unit for rent. My renter also had difficulty with them not fixing issues and would only contact her when the rent is due and still not fix the issues for her. Money hungry PMs that don’t care about losing you thousands of dollars.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Moises Herrera Llanes
Renters Warehouse Milwaukee is managing the new house we just moved into. They have been super responsive, attentive, and wonderful to work with. Cristina is fantastic and we look forward to continues excellent service!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Marcela Garilus
Working with Renters Warehouse has been an excellent experience. We have interacted with many members of their team, they are all very responsive to the many questions we have and they are all very professional and knowledgeable. I highly recommend working with them.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
5 years ago
Reviewed by Zach
Hiring Renters Warehouse was one of the best decisions I have ever made. In the past, I always had problems with my tenants. They never paid rent, they always complained about small maintenance requests, and they always left my property looking like garbage. I hired Renters Warehouse last summer, and since then everything has been a breeze. Owen from the team found me great tenants who pay rent, and they never complain about small maintenance requests like changing lightbulbs or clogged toilets. Josh from the maintenance department is always very good with communication and gets things done fast. I'm happy, and my tenants are happy. Thanks guys, looking forward to another great year of owning a rental property!

Our Team


Carly Stack