Frugality: the Investment Strategy That's Easier Than You Think
When I was in junior high and high school, I used to do long distance road bike races. It's an esoteric, gear-intensive world, where weight is one of the key criteria. Improvements are measured in grams. You want new cranks, get the $150 carbon fiber ones and shave 8g off of your bike weight. One of the things I learned pretty quickly was it's a whole lot easier to take weight off of the rider than it is the bike.
As a relatively new real estate investor, I don't have the connections with banks, lenders, private money, contractors, suppliers, wholesalers, lawyers, accountants, and marketers that most experienced investors do. Yet. But there's no shortcut to experience, and you have to start somewhere. And while I don't yet have the connections and experience with real estate, I do have connections and experience that might be useful. And why not use the experience I earned the hard way and apply it to real estate?
I am an independent musician, a songwriter, a studio owner/producer, and a nationally touring artist (you might've heard the famous four jingle I did for the BP podcast). One of the keys to being successful in that business (where "successful" means "having enough money to eat and pay bills") is by being frugal. Let's examine frugality as a concept, as I see people wrinkle their noses at it when it's mentioned, like you've suggested they give up their house and sleep in a cardboard box in order to maximize their savings rate. Frugality doesn't mean cheap; it just means you don't spend indiscriminately.
I eat out, but not every night.
I have an iphone, but not the newest one.
I drive a nice car with power windows and doors, but it's paid for.
I have a flat screen TV, but no cable.
Frugality means you do a cost/benefit analysis before you spend any amount of money, where you ask yourself, "If I buy this, do I get an equivalent dollar value out of it in return?" and "If I buy this, will it prevent me from buying something else that I'd rather have later?" Sometimes, wildly enough, frugality means spending more money on a high quality item rather than buying cheap crap that you'll have to replace every year (this is why I own nice tools).
Without getting into a philosophical debate on the merits of frugality (Mr. Money Mustache does a bang up job of that), what I'm gonna do instead is give you some of the tips I've used to minimize my overhead, which directly leads to more money I can use to invest in real estate, my IRA, solid gold toilets, or whatever your preference may be. The key to moving to a more frugal lifestyle involves two paradigm shifts, in my experience. One, closely examine your use of the word "need". Human beings need food, water, shelter, and community. They don't need expensive gaming rigs and weekly manicures. No one loves gadgets and good food more than me, but I understand that those things are not necessary for my happiness, but rather rare treats I can enjoy when I've earned them. Two, consider the efforts in frugality a challenge, like climbing Kilimanjaro, and not as a punishment, like you've been grounded by your parents for staying out too late.
1) Ditch the fancy cellphone plan
Man, am I thrilled with this one! For ten years, I paid AT&T over $100 a month for unlimited text/talk/data plus special monthly charges for a smartphone. Then, last year, I discovered MVNOs. Essentially we're talking about companies who purchase blocks of services from the major carriers, and then resell it, a concept I imagine all real estate investors can get on board with.
I switched from AT&T to Airvoice Wireless, and again recently to Cricket Wireless. My phone bill went from $120/month to $35/month. And since Cricket Wireless was recently bought out by AT&T, my services and features are identical. Ok, technically my data is limited to 1GB at 4G speeds, and then throttled after, but with a little bit of data dieting I've never hit the data cap (also, you can expect most of the majors to be throttling or eliminating the unlimited data plans in the near future).
YEARLY SAVINGS: $1,020
The downside: porting your number is a bit scary when you first do it, and forget about shiny palaces of consumerism when you go visit a Cricket Wireless store. They skimp on fanciness and pass the savings on to you. You're also now responsible for buying your own phones, but this is actually a benefit, because that subsidized iphone 5 AT&T sold me for a reduced price in exchange for a new 2 year contract actually ended up costing me around 2 grand.
2) Take the knife to your insurance policies
Between car, home, health, life, and landlord or umbrella policies, you're probably paying a pretty good chunk of coin each year in insurance. While no one wants to be under-insured, I believe each of us has areas we can probably optimize in order to reallocate some cash from the insurance companies (half of whom will do their absolute best to not pay your claim, or drop you if you file one) to ourselves.
With two phone calls, I was able to get my health insurance from $200/month to $45/month, and my car insurance from $1200/year to $700/year.
My car is paid for, and I don't particularly care what it looks like, so I dropped collision and raised the deductible. I'm handy, so if anything minor goes wrong I'll be fixing it anyway. And the money I saved on premiums mean in a few years I'll have a pretty decent car emergency fund built up.
Even if you're happy with your coverage, it's worth spending a half hour once a year calling around and getting some quotes. My regular agent quoted me a policy for the property I'm closing on next week at $1300/year, and another broker got me similar coverage for $750/year. That's bonus cashflow with a ten minute phone call.
YEARLY SAVINGS: $2,360
The downside: As with much of investing, this is about risk tolerance. I have no pre-existing medical conditions, no allergies, good hearing, good vision, and an uncle who is a dentist. I spent one night in a hospital in college after being in car accident, but otherwise never a hospital visit and never a broken bone. I haven't been to a PC physician for an illness since 1999. So I feel comfortable going with a high deductible major medical only plan. I understand for some, or perhaps even many, this isn't something they would feel comfortable with. Do what's right for you and your family.
3) Say goodbye to cable and satellite providers
Honestly, in 2014, I assume that everyone who still has television service is basically ok with paying a convenience tax for the terrible content that's beamed directly into your frontal cortex. And that's not to knock those who do this: a huge chunk of my friends and family do this still! Not coincidentally, every single one of them is wage slave who's planning to work until they drop dead at their desks, hopefully many years from now. Not really the life I'm looking for.
I understand how much it sucks going from 500 channels of programming (where, still, nothing good ever seems to be on) to just the streaming options on a tablet or laptop. But luckily, we live in the future and there are amazing solutions out there.
Personally, I live in a major city, so I use the killer combo of HD antenna ($20 bucks on amazon) for free, HD, over the air broadcasts from the 4 major networks (you can also link this with a DVR, so you can still record your shows) + netflix/amazon prime streaming + chromecast. This combo gives me a nearly unlimited supply of movies and TV shows (netflix/amazon prime), live sports (HD antenna + friends/sports bars), and youtube and ESPN app (chromecast), all shown on my lovely 42" flat screen (bought on sale three years ago). I have so much content I could spend four months never leaving the couch except for bodily functions and have barely tapped the surface of it. "BUT I NEED TO WATCH MY SHOWS RIGHT WHEN THEY AIR!" I hear you yelling, Mom (seriously, the queen of DVRing five shows every night). If you have an addiction you cannot break, or you want to just taper off of it, you can find most of the content streaming on the network website the day after it airs. HGTV, HBOGo, CW, and all the majors. You can have it all, for so much cheaper!
For advanced students, three words: Plex. Media. Server. You're welcome.
YEARLY SAVINGS: $800
The downside: none. Seriously, I've been without cable or satellite for 13 years now, and my life has been 0% the worse for it. The internet has everything you could possibly want, and when you get bored with that, go outside!
------------------------------------------------------
With just those three tips, I saved almost $4,200 per year ($4180, to be exact). To put it in RE terms, that's $350 per MONTH in extra cash flow! If you found a way to squeeze an extra $350/month out of a property, imagine how thrilled you'd be?! If you want to maximize profits, whether it's because you want to acquire more properties, work less/retire early, or look great to investors, this is an easy place to start trimming some fat.
Comment and tell us what tips you've made good use of!
Comments (26)
Excellent Post. The digital diet concept is a practical one, considering we barely come close to the available limit. Getting rid of cable is another excellent step and Netflix pretty much offers everything we need. For people trying to budget for their initial down payment, this post is a great place to start. Thanks for sharing!
Dmitriy Fomichenko, almost 9 years ago
Great blogpost! It's amazing how many people I meet that I know make roughly the same as me and say that they're broke when they pay $100+ to the cable company a month, $200+ for them and their spouse's phone bills, eat out every other night, etc.
Another potential for the mobile phone costs - My husband and I are in a family plan with my in laws. Usually family plans are cheaper. So instead of paying $80 for 2 lines with unlimited calling, texting and internet, we ended up paying $50 for the two of us ($110 for 5 lines with unlimited calling, texting and internet.) This is with T-Mobile. I believe most major providers have these options.
Arianne L., about 9 years ago
JT Thanks for this article. I read this after I saw your post on mine. This is fantastic. I think that you are absolutely right to calculate these cut expenses as increased cashflow. One thing that you might want to think about on top of this is the impact of taxes... You said that you saved $4,180. Assuming that you make over $50,000 per year, you might be taxed at 25%.
You'd have had to get a raise of $5,575, or cash flowed $465 per month to achieve the same level of after tax cashflow! Which do you think is easier - earning over $465 more per month, or employing the simple cost-saving methods you outline here?
Scott Trench, about 10 years ago
@Scott Trench Great point about the tax savings; I didn't even consider that part of it!
I'm also with you about still having fun with some of your disposable income. I was never a guy to drop $200 bucks on a Saturday night, but I didn't miss many nights out in my 20s. By saving on the big expenses and reducing my fixed expenses, I was able to save a pretty healthy chunk of my paycheck and still have a lot of fun.
JT Spangler, about 10 years ago
Great article! I have been very frugal this year following many of the items you mentioned. I'm nearly debt free and will hit the ground running on my first property purchase.
David Padilla, about 10 years ago
@JT Spangler this is a great post, it seems we are a lot alike. Great read.
Brandon L., about 10 years ago
I loved the term "digital diet". We cut cable/satellite in 2010 and haven't missed the DVR. Streaming is a huge time saver too. I can get through a season of any show in a couple nights stead of dragging it out all winter :)
Chad Zaback, about 10 years ago
Awesome post! Kicked cable to the curb a long time ago, just Netflix streaming. When my phone plan ends in February I am re-evaluating this abusive relationship with Verizon. I eat out more than I should, that's a foodie's guilty pleasure but in order to explode in the following months priorities need to be an order.
Frantzces Lys, about 10 years ago
I do all of this too. If i get bored I just get on bigger pockets and read read read!!!
Samuel Maclean, about 10 years ago
These are good ideas. You can go further and use a pay-as-you-go smart phone such as an AT&T Go phone with no data plan, and get your email, etc., over wifi only. Then use a home phone or a computer for long calls and limit the cell phone to short calls away from home. It works. You really don't need email at every moment.
As for health insurance, what is your age? After shopping very carefully, I pay more than 3 1/2 times your previous "high" rate -- for a high-deductible plan covering two people in their late 50s. It's going up 9 percent next year.
Bob H., about 10 years ago
My phone plan is cheaper than Gophone, especially if you're still paying for a home phone line. Minimal data is cheap, and being able to text/email/googlemap away from home is worth it for someone in our business. Frugality isn't about cutting all expenses -- just about getting them to the point where I have 90% of the functionality at 25% of the price. For me that sweet spot is prepaid Cricket wireless with a data plan for $35. I haven't had a landline in my entire adult life, though.
I'm 34, so luckily I fall into the cheapest demo for health insurance; a young man who doesn't smoke and doesn't have any pre-existing conditions. Old is more expensive than young (from an actuarial standpoint), and women are more expensive than men. I expect to pay more each year for healthcare, especially if/when I get married and have kids.
JT Spangler, about 10 years ago
Such a great post. Made me realize I am spending way too much for my AT&T plan... Way too much
Jon Huber, about 10 years ago
WOW! I've found a kindred spirit!!! Loved every word of this post and have lived it to the letter my whole life. It's allowed me to save up the money that I've invested in RE - (all without ever really earning much from my "real" jobs either...
You've nailed it!
Julia Rowling, about 10 years ago
JT,
I'm guessing I'm almost a generation older than you as aluminium and titanium were the weight savers when I was dancing on the pedals... or simply pushing them in squares. ;-)
I have not had a television since 1988, even then it was a hand-me-down and we only watched it periodically for the news or, maybe, Star Trek ... never have had cable.
Our frugal(ish) lifestyle didn't take a hit until we had a kid (well into my 40s) ... they are expensive little things, even if they do think Kijiji is a department store where everyone gets their clothes.
Our means are still modest in comparison to our cohort - many of whom think we are cheap ;-)
Roy N., about 10 years ago
Great post ... we do a lot of these things as well. I appreciate the insight (and bike riding too!) ... awesome!
Nathan Brooks, about 10 years ago
Great article! I already do almost everything I'm supposed to do to cut spending. I don't use a TV (watch things on the computer), I have a cell phone plan at $45/month, I hardly ever eat out, I play board games for entertainment, I shop at Goodwill, etc. I've been doing this for years and have been able to sink my savings into rental properties that are paying me back hundreds of dollars a month. It allowed me to grow quickly.
Dawn Anastasi, about 10 years ago
Thanks, Dawn! I've followed your deals since your podcast episode -- I really like your model.
JT Spangler, about 10 years ago
How do you get internet? I want to cut cable, but when I asked comcast about it, they said my bill would only go down $10! I'm in WA and I can't find a different solution for internet and it's frustrating.
I'm also very glad I read this because I was just about to upgrade my phone with sprint to the galaxay note 4, but this helped me realize that my note 2 still works fine! And my contract is up with sprint, so I can take my working phone with me to a different service! To bad my wife just renewed her contract last month :(
Tyson Bumgarner, about 10 years ago
Personally, I've never lived in a city that didn't have at least two different ISPs. What I've done here in Nashville is call comcast and tell them I'm canceling my service. They transfer you to the retention department, whose job it is to offer you whatever they can to make sure you don't leave, because it's far cheaper to keep an existing customer than acquire a new one (yet another parallel with us buy and hold investors).
You can also do what my brother does, which is every year switch providers to get their year long introductory rate.
Understand that they will try and charge you as much as they can, and you'll have to make a solid effort to convince them you will leave because the prices are too high.
Congrats on your phone! MVNOs are really pretty slick, and there are several out there that use Sprint's network (should that be something you want). :)
JT Spangler, about 10 years ago
Nice article.
My wife and I started budgeting our income monthly about 4 months ago. What we found is budgeting made it easier/possible to objectively look at our expenses and figure out where we can reduce. Here's what we've changed:
1. Dumped cable, added NetFlix & NHL Center Ice (still a sports fan). Savings of $1,200 per year.
2. Reduced our gas usage. I used to use 1.5 tanks a week going to work, which is expensive and not good on my 20 year old Ranger. Now ride to work on a van pool and use about a tank a month. Savings of $2,400 per year (not including maintenance)
3. Reduced our cell phone plan. We were on the "get a shiny new iPhone every year" plan witch cost a ton of money. We decided to not get the newest phone and joined our account with some friends. Bill went from $220 to $60 per month. Savings of $1,920 per year.
4. We eat at home more and watch what we are buying at the store. APPX. savings of $150 per month.
In the last 4 months we have reduced our expenses by over $600, which has been awesome!
Sam McPeek, about 10 years ago
Yeah, Sam! That's amazing. Food is an area I spend more than I should, because I like to eat and drink. But at least that expense is variable, so if I really need to I can tighten it down anytime.
JT Spangler, about 10 years ago
Great article. I implemented all these ideas over a year ago and do not feel like I'm missing out on anything.
Sam Archuleta, about 10 years ago
I've done just about all of these things. Our television is a combination of Chromecast. used for keeping up with currently running tv shows, and Netflix for everything else.
Ditto on the cellphone carriers. They're greedy as all get out. Once my contract is finished Janurary 2016, or possibly before If I choose to pay, I'm switching to prepaid. I recently reduced my monthly bill to their lowest plan available to me and....it's 60$ down from 70$. The maximum I can save is 10$!!
When I switch to prepaid I'll be paying 15$ a month. Think of those savings!
I live a very frugal life while enjoying mild luxuries because my expenses are so low - I only spend 70$ a month on groceries but I eat healthy & well.
Shawn Hartwell, about 10 years ago
JT Spangler, about 10 years ago
Dude this was an amazing blog post! You and I are very similar in this stuff. My iPhone is a 5, but it has a cracked screen... but somehow I'm okay with that! :) Keep up the great writing.
I'm going to go share this all over Social media now! :)
Brandon Turner, about 10 years ago
Thanks, man! But I'm still insanely jealous of the deals you find in rural Washington.
JT Spangler, about 10 years ago